Brett
Guest
My teams are finished, it's time to move to basketball
(and professional pickleball)
(and professional pickleball)
This team is very puzzling. Yeah, they lost to Vanderbilt where they looked unprepared and to Tennessee inNow I understand why the last Bama Coach retired last season. This year team looked awful on paper and in practice. IMHO
Last year everybody on TUG was demanding that more teams be included in the playoffs. More teams, more mediocre teams get included. Yes , one of these medocre teams could get hot and win it all. Does that mean that they are the best team in college football? Playoffs produce upsets and are not a good way to determine who really has the best team.College Football Playoff's credibility taking a hit as race is littered with mediocre contenders down stretch
College Football Playoff's credibility taking a hit as race is littered with mediocre contenders down stretch
Maybe ballooning the field to 12 teams went a little overboard ... at least for this seasonwww.cbssports.com
Richard
So what WOULD be a good way to determine who really has the best team? Maybe just let some sports writers or group of AD's in a back room vote preseason so the teams don't actually have to play any games at all?Last year everybody on TUG was demanding that more teams be included in the playoffs. More teams, more mediocre teams get included. Yes , one of these medocre teams could get hot and win it all. Does that mean that they are the best team in college football? Playoffs produce upsets and are not a good way to determine who really has the best team.
Of course, the bottom line is that what this is really all about is the money. The NCAA (and a number of conferences and colleges) will cash in with the expanded playoffs. That is what this is really all about.
The problems with playoffs games in baseball, basketball, football and all NCAA playoff games. These are college students and not gladiators for the pleasure of large money making alumnI, corporations and colleges. IMHO.So what WOULD be a good way to determine who really has the best team? Maybe just let some sports writers or group of AD's in a back room vote preseason so the teams don't actually have to play any games at all?
Large field playoffs seem to work just fine in virtually every other major sport. Nobody seems to feel like playoffs are a failure because a wildcard team wins the Superbowl or World Series.
The fact of the matter is that there's 130ish FBS teams and a 12 game schedule will never provide a large enough sample of results to determine anything definitive due to schedule imbalance. So at the end of the regular season, pick a statistically large enough field of teams and let them decide things on the field. It's how March Madness works and it's the way CFB should be.