I think, that only holds true (WW 1 = 50 calories) if you are eating carbs. Per the Biggest Loser book I'm eating approx 1,500 calories just most of them are in vegetables & fruit & whole grains. I'm really seeing how 1/2 the plate must be veggies. There are very few carbs on the diet. Once the 30 days are up I'll probably go back to the WW way but make sure I eat more "healthy" type foods. I was snacking too much on WW desserts, 100 Calorie snack paks, jello cups, diet pepsi, etc.. instead of grabbing a fruit or veggies to eat. I'm hoping this will help me lose some of the cravings. However, tonight I'm in a real "pickle" as I didn't realize that I had a girl scout and PTA meeting so, no chance to make dinner. I'll probably repeat yesterday's lunch. To stay on track.
Actually no. There is a math formula which derives a point value by calculating total calorie value, fat & fiber grams to = point value. I've ran through it a few times and it's not restricted to carbs. (That's the nerd in me talking right there!)
That said, I get what you are saying about snacking and broad food choices. I understand what you are doing. Hang in there.