I agree with you - Mandatory resorts have to be part of the “club”, but it doesn’t state that it has to be VSN - it could be Abound if you read it liberally. There are a few logical issues I have with what is being suggested. But since I don’t want to risk this post being sent to the memory hole I’ll not state them.
Agreed - this was discussed way back when.... here:
https://tugbbs.com/forums/threads/mandatory-resorts-must-they-really-be-in-the-network.294047/
To me, the bottom line is:
a) nothing forces "the Club" (Vistana East Vacation Club) to continue to use VSN as "the Network" - such affiliation is a result of a Network Affiliation Agreement, which presumably can be terminated (say if "the Network" a.k.a. VSN decided to cease operating);
b) given MVC now owns/controls the network it could easily decide to terminate the Network Affiliation Agreement;
c) even if it decided to continue with the Network Affiliation Agreement, it completely controls "the Network" and can change it's rules, regulations and procedures as it sees fit; and
d) it doesn't even need to change the existing rules to change the "points" values assigned to any VOI as The Vistana East Vacation Club docs and Vistana Signature Network docs make clear:
Club Operator also reserves the right to revise the assignment of Club Points based on the Assignment Factors. As a consequence, the relative reservation power of Club Points in the Club may vary from the relative reservation power of StarOptions in the Network in the future.
The number of StarOptions assigned represents the reservation power of a given Vacation Ownership Interest within the Network is based on such
factors as relative Network Member demand for the particular Network Resort, seasonality of the VOI, Unit type assigned to the VOI Use Rights
associated with the VOI, Network Resort type, Network Member use patterns, and availability of Vacation Periods for reservation at the
particular Network Resort ("Assignment Factors"). Network Operator reserves the right, in its sole discretion, to revise the number of
StarOptions required for reservations within the Network annually, each without Network Member consent.
So there isn't even a need to get rid of "VSN" so to speak; they could simply amend references to "StarOptions" or "Club Points" to mean "Abound Points" and use the existing power in the existing agreements to completely change the point values.
It sounds like you are kind of forced. The only option going forward is to use Abound points or your home resort week. No option for StarOptions there from what I read from the insider. How will they handle HomeOption reservations at a home resort? Not everyone bought something nice and even to book a single week in a single unit. I doubt they would force them into the Abound point charts and eliminate the StarOption chart.
They will likely have to maintain a "HomeOption" chart in line with the ownership interests baked into various trusts. While those charts were aligned with the existing VSN charts, nothing requires VSN or the VSN charts to continue (the HomeOption charts will continue as standalone guidance for use of those who own "HomeOptions").