This is a fascinating thread -- we are trying to determine if this is a good time to buy timeshares.
It's the same answer as always -- if you can afford the upfront (and assume you flush the upfront payment) and are not concerned about the ongoing MF's and probably increases in MF's then it's a great time, as always, to be a buyer. But we should be prudent about making sure all bases are covered before further commitments. It's not an investment, it's an expense. If you can salvage a little bit of the upfront cost someday, then good for you, but don't buy it assuming it will appreciate.
I don't know the details of what's Perry's expecting, but in my opinion, it's going to get worse, alot worse. I'm a predictor of a Great Recession, not a return of the Great Depression, more like 1974 than 1933. Personal (and corporate) liquidity is what matters, having sufficient cash reserves. I am thrilled and encouraged by Ben Bernanke's actions, but all this will still take time to resolve. It's one thing to talk about massive layoffs, it's another to experience the reality of what comes from having massive layoffs.
This will be very painful for many good folks. If you have the cash reserves to survive it, it will be a feast to pick up cheap assets of all kinds, including timeshares. But timeshares are different because they will never meaningfully appreciate, they are a toy -- you might get a modest profit, but it won't generate the returns a different asset might. Take the same money and buy discounted homes or stocks that yield something, and use the dividend to buy your timeshare.
So please, don't bang on Perry, don't bang on Boca, these only distract the issue. It's the same as always, use only your play money for timeshares, money you'll never miss.
And please don't minimize my comments by asking if I understand the Fed -- yes I do - and despite the Fed, it's going to get much worse before it gets better. But I may differ from Perry in that I don't predict a dollar crash, and I think we will be emerging from this in 12 months.
So, during that time, and, please forgive me for being a viking, but I will be an opportunistic buyer of true assets, with timeshares, as always, treated as a toy and bought with gambling money.