Are they just throwing stuff at the wall to see what sticks?
Yes they are. Or to take it a step further, of course they are. Wyndham made it quite clear that Privileges is a work in progress and nothing will be decided upon for sure until it is closer to the roll out date. Until they make the final official announcement of what the levels and benefits will be everything is subject to change. Since the new program date is set for late 2020 they have plenty of time to come up with ideas, "see what sticks", before they decide what the final product will be. They are absolutely looking for owners feedback to find what is most important and appealing to us. What will entice us to buy or give us a reason to keep buying more.
So what was it that convinced you to buy enough points to be VIP or to buy more to get to a higher VIP level? Here is my list in order of importance.
1. The discount
2. The upgrades
3. Free reservation transactions
4. Unlimited housekeeping credits
5. Ability to request specific units (To make this a real benefit the layouts with the unit numbers should be available for all the resorts when you bring up the information on each resort.)
6. Points Deposit
7. Guest Confirmations
8. RARP and APR
9. Early check-in
10. RCI instant search and book.
11. Worldwide external exchange deposit unit size upgrade
12. Exclusive VIP check-in area
13. Midweek clean and tidy
I've never used these two so didn't know what order of priority they should get.
14. Access to Margaritaville inventory
15. Extended Plus Partners travel booking window
16. Daily newspaper. With the news sites on the internet and everything going digital this isn't as big a deal as it used to be. However I really like getting the local paper to find out what's going on in the area and see the local restaurant ads.