czar
TUG Member
Lots of options on VRBO. If you want to stay on St. John, I'd pick a villa near Coral Bay since you'll be closer to Cruz Bay when stay at WSJ. Lots of more affordable options on STT. Personally, if I stayed on STT, I'd opt to stay there at the beginning of my trip so that I ended the trip on STJ. STT has beautiful bays but the island itself is more crowded and dirtier.
Another option if y'all have valid passports is to venture over to one of the British Virgin Islands, such as Virgin Gorda. Villas in the BVI tend to be pricier, but they are just gorgeous. Definitely hit The Baths if you can, whether you stay here or not.
Another option might be to fly to San Juan or Miami and take a 4 or 5 night Caribbean cruise, then fly to STT when you return. Or look into chartering a sailboat yacht for a few nights.
Thanks those are great suggestions. I'd be up for the sailboat if the kids were a little oder, but they range from 0-7, so it limited us somewhat.
I'm debating between two options - booking fights through SJU and staying 2-3 days on PR; or, booking flights +2 days out of STT, booking a cancellable res on STT and keep looking each day for the improbable sighting of 2 nights we need in April at WSJ!