I don't know if it is a great one or not, but we're intrigued.
Hotel on the Cay #1597
Hotel 4(2) No kitchen
2/4/23 23TPU via RCI Weeks
This is an older hotel that just happens to be sitting on its own very small island a few hundred yards off the coast of St. Croix near Christiansted. There is a boat that shuttles back and forth--complimentary for hotel guests--a tiki bar, some sand, turltes, and fish. The pool has been broken for years, as has the "water feature" and there is no sign that any of that will change. There is a dorm-sized fridge, coffee pot, microwave, and toaster. Definitely different from the glitzy resorts we sometimes enjoy, but the reviews commonly point to a very welcoming staff. This might be exactly what we need for a good mid-winter break a couple years from now.
(Edited to add unit size/kitchen info)