Disney is known as a high end TS product and really the Holy Grail of TS. Although I spent $4 on my Wyndham TS, I’m willing to spend $10k on a Disney TS once the child situation with the wife resolves.
Wyndham TS don’t retain resale value that well. Although Disney TS retail about 50 percent, you are lucky to get even 2 percent with Wyndham. If you try to sell your 300k Bonnett Creek in two weeks, you are lucky to sell for $600. That’s how I got 430k pts for $4.
I love Wyndham but hate their sales practices. Disney generally has four star resorts. Besides Bonnett Creek, Wyndhak generally has three star resorts. RCI has a lot of two star resorts.
How many timeshare resorts have you personally stayed at? Also where you are getting the star ratings from?
When I'm investigating a resort we've never stayed at I end up reading reviews on Trip Advisor. I find a number of the reviews completely worthless and the star ratings flawed. You have to weed out the reviews from people who have no idea how timeshares work and expected a luxury hotel with daily maid service and room service.
We've stayed at half a dozen HGVC resorts and they all get 5 stars on Trip Advisor except for one that got 4.5 stars. We've stayed at 55+ resorts in 14 states through Wyndham and RCI so I have an excellent basis for comparison. While all the Hilton Grand Vacation Club resorts we've stayed at were nice only one should get even 4.5 stars. Yet of the 8 Wyndham resorts that I just now looked up on Trip Advisor that we've stayed at in no more than the last year or so none got above 4.5 stars. And all of them were as nice as and in most cases better than the one Hilton Grand Vacation Club resorts I thought worthy of 4.5 stars.
I think a good part of the reason Wyndham isn't rated higher is because of the huge number of renters. But some owners are equally as guilty of having no idea about what they booked. My all time favorite was an owner who recently completely trashed St. Thomas Margaritaville in one of the Wydham Facebook groups I belong to. She booked a studio, not even a studio deluxe, then ranted about how small it was and that it didn't have a stovetop just a microwave. The general response was yeah, apparently you didn't even look at what you booked!
She also complained how awful the service at the bar was and how they ignored her. We've been at this resort for 6 days now and I haven't had to wait for more than one or two people to be waited on to order our drinks during happy hour when the bar is the busiest. None of the people we've enjoyed sitting with and talking to have had any complaints about the service either. The complainers and people who can't be bothered to do any checking at all about the accommodations are the kinds of people whose reviews inaccurately impact the star ratings.