We go to Atlantis every year and always have a blast. However, I’ve definitely noticed the problems with cost cutting and deferred maintenance; the condition of the resort is deteriorating and doesn’t feel quite up to snuff. We explored Baha Mar last year for the first time and were initially blown away by the “sparkle” of the place... until lackluster experiences at several F&B venues as well as around the property. We’ve always found the service and F&B quality at Atlantis to range from very good to excellent, and Baha Mar was almost universally poor. The facility is definitely “nice” and “new,” but it didn’t take long to wish to be back at Atlantis. Everyone agreed there was no reason to go to Baha Mar again unless you were after Instagram photos.
Long story short, if you want to have fun as a family or a group, and you aren’t a “look at me” celeb or social media influencer, skip Baha Mar and go to Atlantis. If you want upscale, stay at the Cove.