I can’t speak for the other, but I LOVE LOVE LOVE Bonnet Creek. I take my kids every year, usually with a grandma accompanying. There are a lot of pools- two have slides, there’s a splash pad, two or three lazy rivers, hot tubs at every pool. My kids are 10 now, and a 1year old. We’ve been going at least 5 years- something for everyone. There are restaurants/bars outside all along the property and onsite arcade, mini golf, and planned daily activities for kids AND adults. The pools are outside and heated. We were there last week. There is a shuttle to the parks, but you’re right across the street from Disney.