I agree. My guess is some sort of defective deed issue vs. no deed at all. MVC must have seen a recorded deed of some type to transfer ownership on its books. There was another thread about a similar issue. MVC does not do a title search or even a rudimentary comparison of prior deed to current deed, IFIRC. If they deed is defective, they should demand that MVC remove them from the HOA's ownership rolls, as they are not entitled to be a member, and HOA cannot bill them. If they refuse, an attorney could easily sway them, as the HOA is 100% in the wrong if they do not own.