I was already paying about $12K for home, car (with 2 cars and 4 drivers (2 under 25) with Allstate. Meanwhile, my company took away the car (which they insured) they had provided me for years. SO I went a bought myself a car. I called the insurance and they told me it would be $3,500 extra per year for the additional car - insurance would now be over $15K.
So, I shopped around and called NJM - they ended up insuring the 3 cars and the home for around $6K. Literally the exact same terms.
However, my daughter had an accident, totaling one of our cars and the car she hit. Now my insurance is up to $11K. We have had 2 clean years with no claims whatsoever - hoping my premium will come down or we will shop around again.