The “conspiracy” was actually just reading the Abound Exchange Procedures and it was pretty clear to me what they intended to do: “Exchange Company shall have the right to forecast anticipated reservations and use of the Accommodations and is authorized to demand balance, reserve, deposit, or rent the Accommodations for the purpose of facilitating the use or future use of the Accommodations or other benefits made available to Program Members through the Program in its sole discretion.”
It does not matter if the Vistana weeks available in Abound come from owner deposits that didn't even occur yet (based on “future anticipated demand”) or from inventory owned by Vistana. Bottom line is there is no paragraph I could find in the VSN or Lagunamar governing documents that allows Abound to book its own inventory in ways not available to the other owners even at the same time with the other owners let alone prior to the actual opening of the Home Resort Reservation Period. This is worse than I anticipated. Also, as it was to be expected, once they see inventory in Abound, people started to book there Vistana weeks and deposit their (again Vistana) weeks. It is as clear as it can be that people will book wherever they can find inventory (especially prime weeks that are hard to book), and this attracts deposits. It is not the other way around, as much as the Marriott apologists have tried to convince us.
I still have a hard time comprehending what is unclear about: “Required Reservation Periods. There must be at least one “Home Resort Reservation Period.” The Home Resort Reservation Period must permit a Member to request a reservation, without competition from anyone who is not assigned a Vacation Ownership Interest in a Vacation Unit that is the same Unit Type as the Member’s Unit Type and for any Vacation Period in the same Season as the Member’s Vacation Week, provided that nobody else has reserved the Vacation Period and that no other Persons have the exclusive right to reserve the Vacation Period. The Home Resort Reservation Period must last at least sixty (60) days. The Home Resort Reservation Period cannot begin more than eighteen months before the Check-in Day for any Use Period.” Marriott is making a joke out of the resort rules if the resort owners are now in competition for every week with the owners of 92 other resorts.
Do we still believe in a rule-based system? Not so sure.