T_R_Oglodyte
TUG Lifetime Member
Interesting, given how often we see/hear this used ... did she provide some recognized authority (e.g. Fowler's) to support her assertion?
I think the use of up/down can be quite useful from a teaching point of view - e.g. a resident of Windsor, Ontario driving UP to Detroit to see the Red Wings play hockey.![]()
Yes - I think it's common usage to for "up" to mean "north" and down to mean "south". They drove down to San Francisco to go to school and came up to Washington to see us. People in San Fransisco go down to LA, and people in LA up to San Fransisco or Portland or Vancouver.
Up and down can also refer to heading into or leaving mountains or hills, though, regardless of direction.
*******
How about "can" and "may"? At Christmas, DD reminded me of how I taught the kds the difference. They might ask if they "can" have a cookie, and I would say "of course you can". Then as they were reaching for the cookie jar I would say "... but you may not". Looking back on it now, DD said it was a wonderful method. She didn't care for it so much at the time, though, when she was the one going for the cookies.