Don's favorite has always been Barony Beach Club oceanfront, mine is SurfWatch and I'd be happy staying in any section because the draw for me is the large natural footprint of the entire resort. It's such a beautiful place. GO doesn't appeal to either of us because in our opinion it's just too many buildings situated in the footprint, but if it were the only one of the "Big 4" available during high season, we'd take it. We've also stayed many times at Harbor Point in Shelter Cove during low season and love the view over Broad Creek, and its mid-island location makes it convenient to eat, shop and visit anyplace on the island.
But the reason I'm responding to the specific quoted posts is, our 7YO grandson thinks that Barony's gardenview pool with the slide is "THE BEST POOL EVER GRANDMA AND PEOPLE CAN SLEEP IN THESE BUILDINGS LIKE A HOTEL?!?!" His 4YO sister also loves it despite not being tall enough yet to use the slide.
Now that we live on the island our kids and grandkids visit 2-3 times a year and we use Day Passes at both Barony and SurfWatch. Back in April we were at the Barony pool when Caden got to ride the slide for the first time. He loved it so much that we used the app to book a night for the four of them during their next trip in August - and I don't think we'll ever be able to give him anything that compares.
So don't discount Barony if kids are along, whether it's in the oceanfront/oceanside section adjacent to the beach or in gardenview behind the Westin hotel next door.
(I don't know if it matters but when I asked Don how he'd answer here, he told me to make sure I let the OP know that All Y'all's at Barony has the best french fries of anywhere on the island. I think he's hungry for lunch.)