SueDonJ
Moderator
- Joined
- Jul 26, 2006
- Messages
- 16,713
- Reaction score
- 5,982
- Location
- Massachusetts and Hilton Head Island
- Resorts Owned
- Marriott Barony Beach and SurfWatch
And when a Marriott owner exchanges into a unit at their home resort, they also get the view category exchanged, and not downgraded for what they own?
I think the Westin Kanaapali front desk just has the unit disappointment response on recording. I'm not sure I agree that all owners should only get the category they own period. If I owned at WKORV (and I don't) and was paying the really high MF, I would want to have a shot at a better view in my home resort than someone trading or using StarOptions to get in who pays a fraction of the annual fees. View category does not exchange with units through Starwood, I understand that it does, depending on location, with Marriott.
If a Marriott owner exchanges back into their home resort it's in one of two ways, either as an II exchanger or through converting a DC-enrolled Week into Points and using those Points to reserve the stay. None of them are given the same priority as owners using their own weeks, they're all considered to be exchangers.
With II exchanges no view is guaranteed; some resorts disregard the view type that's attached to the II confirmation and instead use the Priority Placement system that places owners exchanging back in somewhere below owners using their own weeks and above other exchangers, and, other resorts place exchangers into the units that are attached to the II confirmations but maybe below owners on the list.
With DC Points stays, if there are different views available then there are different Points requirements for each view, and the user chooses which one s/he wants. I think the same thing about those as I do about owners using their own weeks at their own resorts - they all should be placed into what was "purchased." We haven't figured out on TUG yet where the resorts that use a Priority Placement system fit DC Points users into the mix, except we're pretty sure they don't have the same priority as owners using their own weeks.
It sounds like Marriott uses a similar disclaimer as Starwood does and if you make requests they'll note them but they'll tell you that nothing is guaranteed. I've always thought that unit placement with exchanges is a crap shoot. Sometimes you get lucky and sometimes you don't, but being an owner exchanging back in doesn't mean you automatically get an upgrade.
Last edited: