• Welcome to the FREE TUGBBS forums! The absolute best place for owners to get help and advice about their timeshares for more than 32 years!

    Join Tens of Thousands of other owners just like you here to get any and all Timeshare questions answered 24 hours a day!
  • TUG started 32 years ago in October 1993 as a group of regular Timeshare owners just like you!

    Read about our 32nd anniversary: Happy 32nd Birthday TUG!
  • TUG has a YouTube Channel to produce weekly short informative videos on popular Timeshare topics!

    All subscribers auto-entered to win all free TUG membership giveaways!

    Visit TUG on Youtube!
  • TUG has now saved timeshare owners more than $24,000,000 dollars just by finding us in time to rescind a new Timeshare purchase! A truly incredible milestone!

    Read more here: TUG saves owners more than $24 Million dollars
  • Wish you could meet up with other TUG members? Well look no further as this annual event has been going on for years in Orlando! How to Attend the TUG January Get-Together!
  • Now through the end of the year you can join or renew your TUG membership at the lowest price ever offered! Learn More!
  • Sign up to get the TUG Newsletter for free!

    Tens of thousands of subscribing owners! A weekly recap of the best Timeshare resort reviews and the most popular topics discussed by owners!
  • Our official "end my sales presentation early" T-shirts are available again! Also come with the option for a free membership extension with purchase to offset the cost!

    All T-shirt options here!
  • A few of the most common links here on the forums for newbies and guests!

vero beach

Yes we stayed in April 2010
 
With that many weeks, you must be paying lots of$$$ On Maintenence fees.
I have 7 timeshares and I pay a lot in Maintenence too!

I think the MFs are reasonable because before we discovered the upscale branded timeshare market, we stayed in small hotel rooms for $400-$600+ per night. Now we can stay in 1 and 2 bedrooms with kitchens for a fraction of the cost.
 
We bought DVC over 10 years ago, with the idea of vacationing with family, those plans worked out well.

Now we are adding on for our retirement and senior years. DVC is the most senior friendly timeshare out there, especially if you are flying. Honestly, you can vacation there well into your 80's, with not worrying about driving, luggage handling, and grocery shopping. We looked into buying a condo,
but when we figured things out, it makes much more sense to buy into DVC. Sure there is more economical ways but everything has a price, and sometimes the more economical ways are more expensive.

DVC has a strong resale, rental, family interest (meaning family will always visit you) value that if something should happen to us we would feel protected in a way that our family would not be in a bind over these timeshares.

My point is that piece of mind has value to it. How much value depends on your value of time, safety, convenience, and added worries.

Totally agree!
 
Almost all of my DVC stays over the past 18 years have been on exchanges. VB, OKW, VWL, SSR, BCV, BWV and AKV. As many as 10 exchanges at one time for a family trip. But it is more difficult, for WDW it's essentially only SSR 1 BR with a rare AKV or AKV 1 BR for the past 3 years. I haven't looked at VB & HH but would figure they are available off season but not the rest.

Hi Dean, with all the DVC points you own and have owned over the year, why would you do DVC stays on exchange?
 
Hi Dean, with all the DVC points you own and have owned over the year, why would you do DVC stays on exchange?
It has been much cheaper to do the exchanges and rent out the points. We've been able to stay where we were happy doing so. As I said, we'd planned to sell all but the 25 points but never got around to it. While I think exchanging in is workable for us going forward, I don't think it has the options it did 10 years ago. For a novice buying to exchange in would not be a good choice IMO but for someone looking to get to Disney and other places, owning something they could use but might be able to exchange in with could be a workable plan.
 
It has been much cheaper to do the exchanges and rent out the points. We've been able to stay where we were happy doing so. As I said, we'd planned to sell all but the 25 points but never got around to it. While I think exchanging in is workable for us going forward, I don't think it has the options it did 10 years ago. For a novice buying to exchange in would not be a good choice IMO but for someone looking to get to Disney and other places, owning something they could use but might be able to exchange in with could be a workable plan.
That’s what I’m hoping my HGVC will be good for. I’ll try to exchange into the park DVC resorts. If not then the HGVC resorts aren’t too far away. I may still buy some DVC though! Lol!
 
That’s what I’m hoping my HGVC will be good for. I’ll try to exchange into the park DVC resorts. If not then the HGVC resorts aren’t too far away. I may still buy some DVC though! Lol!
Owning DVC points would allow you to book a DVC resort other than SSR. Saratoga shows up the most in RCI. Other DVC resorts are few and far between in RCI these days. I occasionally see OKW in RCI. And I personally have not seen AKL in ages in RCI.

We also use our DVC points to tack an extra two or three days onto a 7 night exchange thru RCI. Or after a 7 night exchange/Getaway with Interval International into Sheraton or Marriott, we book two or three days onsite at DVC. 9 or 10 day vacations work out perfectly for us. For May I have two one bedrooms booked at Marriott Harbour Lake for our daughters and a Sheraton Vistana Villages for my husband and I and then we move over to Disney property for the last few days using DVC points.
 
That’s what I’m hoping my HGVC will be good for. I’ll try to exchange into the park DVC resorts. If not then the HGVC resorts aren’t too far away. I may still buy some DVC though! Lol!
It's a high risk high high reward play but if you're OK with the off property resorts in HGVC (which are overall nicer than DVC resorts), OK with SSR or similar, can do a 1 BR and plan far out; you're chances of success are high.
 
We bought DVC over 10 years ago, with the idea of vacationing with family, those plans worked out well.

Now we are adding on for our retirement and senior years. DVC is the most senior friendly timeshare out there, especially if you are flying. Honestly, you can vacation there well into your 80's, with not worrying about driving, luggage handling, and grocery shopping. We looked into buying a condo,
but when we figured things out, it makes much more sense to buy into DVC. Sure there is more economical ways but everything has a price, and sometimes the more economical ways are more expensive.

DVC has a strong resale, rental, family interest (meaning family will always visit you) value that if something should happen to us we would feel protected in a way that our family would not be in a bind over these timeshares.

My point is that piece of mind has value to it. How much value depends on your value of time, safety, convenience, and added worries.

"My point is that piece of mind has value to it." - I agree!
 
Unless there is a savings, it makes no sense to buy. Obviously it depends on what you're comparing to, for DVC it's comparing to on property cash and/or DVC rental.

I think - as long as you can afford it - there are many purchases that make sense for emotional reasons, enjoyment and peace of mind. Like I said before, DVC is a luxury, non-essential purchase. If we are strictly looking at financial reasons, then buying a DVC timeshare does not make sense at all. Going back to Disney again and again would, technically, be unnecessary. I hope I am communicating this properly. While I am a Disney owner, and purchased most of my points resale, I think it was a frivolous purchase but one we can afford and we did try to maximize our value. If we based decisions solely on saving money, we would own very little expect our primary home and 2 cars. We would have one pet instead of four including three expensive pure breeds. In fact, if we were solely concerned with financial savings, we would never buy a new car or go on a vacation far from home. In the olden days, when I was a kid, we never went on vacation more than 200 miles away from home (always by car) and that seemed like a luxury.
 
Last edited:
I think - as long as you can afford it - there are many purchases that make sense for emotional reasons, enjoyment and peace of mind. Like I said before, DVC is a luxury, non-essential purchase. If we are strictly looking at financial reasons, then buying a DVC timeshare does not make sense at all. Going back to Disney again and again would, technically, be unnecessary. I hope I am communicating this properly. While I am a Disney owner, and purchased most of my points resale, I think it was a frivolous purchase but one we can afford and we did try to maximize our value. If we based decisions solely on saving money, we would own very little expect our primary home and 2 cars. We would have one pet instead of four including three expensive pure breeds. In fact, if we were solely concerned with financial savings, we would never buy a new car or go on a vacation far from home. In the olden days, when I was a kid, we never went on vacation more than 200 miles away from home (always by car) and that seemed like a luxury.
Sure but my point is that if it doesn't make financial sense at least compared to on property, it doesn't make sense at all. Just to be a member of the club doesn't make any sense.
 
Well apparently I've lost all sense then. I put an offer in on a contract tonight. We'll see what the reply is and I'll let you know how it goes. They may just tell me to pound sand as I offered much less than they were asking but right around what they have been selling for so we'll see.
 
Well apparently I've lost all sense then. I put an offer in on a contract tonight. We'll see what the reply is and I'll let you know how it goes. They may just tell me to pound sand as I offered much less than they were asking but right around what they have been selling for so we'll see.

If you think you will have fun and you have the money, then go for it! Which DVC resort did you make an offer on?
 
We were able to stay at Disney Vero Beach on an RCI exchange about8 years ago. Is it harder to get now?

I exchanged once their in 2009 via II and in April 2015 via RCI (20 TPUS). Haven't seen it show up again.....
 
Well apparently I've lost all sense then. I put an offer in on a contract tonight. We'll see what the reply is and I'll let you know how it goes. They may just tell me to pound sand as I offered much less than they were asking but right around what they have been selling for so we'll see.
Good luck.
 

Nice resort. I have seen their price per point all over the map so you should get one at a good price. If the one you made the offer on does not work out, I am sure you will find another contract at the price you are willing to pay.
 
Ended up in a multiple offer situation so I had to amend my offer. I’ll find out after 5 tonight if I got it. It’s a big contract so it’s not cheap but it will pay for itself over time so I’m ok with it.
 
Multiple offers on a timeshare are rare. How big is your contract?
 
That’s what I’m hoping my HGVC will be good for. I’ll try to exchange into the park DVC resorts. If not then the HGVC resorts aren’t too far away. I may still buy some DVC though! Lol!
Pretty much just 1br SSR nowadays. There was a time a few years ago that exchanging was great. But now there are less opportunities and locations. Also RCI has increased the exchange fees plus now DVC collects $190 a week when exchanging in.

Sent from my SM-T217S using Tapatalk
 
I suspect DVC does not want folks to exchange because RCI does not have good options for trading into. That may be one way they keep their resale prices high. DVC is not a trader.
 
I suspect DVC does not want folks to exchange because RCI does not have good options for trading into. That may be one way they keep their resale prices high. DVC is not a trader.
Overall they have been encouraging trading somewhat. I suspect their agreement with RCI requires a certain volume of exchanges
 
It's a high risk high high reward play but if you're OK with the off property resorts in HGVC (which are overall nicer than DVC resorts), OK with SSR or similar, can do a 1 BR and plan far out; you're chances of success are high.

Which HGV resorts do you feel are nicer?
 
Top