Gardens of West Maui is clean. It's noisy for exchangers, with the roosters next door. Consolidated tends to put exchangers in building one, by the road and the farm. I wouldn't hesitate to stay there myself, but I would call the management company ahead of time and insist on a unit away from the rooster noise.
I found it to be extremely clean during our stays. No complaints at all from me.. We stayed in building 3 both times as owners.