M&M in Arizona
Guest
- Joined
- Apr 20, 2024
- Messages
- 3
- Reaction score
- 1
- Resorts Owned
- Westin Nanea
Has anyone any info about this company? They pop up in all searches.
They claim they are not brokers or licensed real estate agents and thus can not provide advise on pricing. Which they legally can't. They use this to their advantage. Timeshares Only is another such outfit. They however feed resales that actually have value through a related broker company.There are only two kinds of listing companies. One would be the true scammers who do absolutely nothing for the hundreds or thousands of upfront fees. They don’t even have individualized ads. They pretend to market your timeshare through events or directly to corporate entities. All of that would be lies. The second kind would be Sell My Timeshare Now. They have been around for many years and they do provide individualized ads. However, that doesn’t make them worth the upfront fee. There are many, many over priced timeshares for sale or rent at their website. They don’t care that they collect their upfront fee for someone to advertise their Westgate timeshare for sale at $50,000.
I am not sure of the legality, but SMTN is in fact providing advice on pricing. SMTN's website includes a section called "What's my timeshare worth?". You fill in your resort information and on the last step you are required to enter your name, email and phone number. When you submit, you get this:They claim they are not brokers or licensed real estate agents and thus can not provide advise on pricing. Which they legally can't. They use this to their advantage. Timeshares Only is another such outfit. They however feed resales that actually have value through a related broker company.
Did you read the messages in the searches in which you say they popped up?
I was surprised to see 28% below $1,000. I suspect that many of these may be desperate owners who have dropped their listing prices after getting no inquiries. I am not really surprised to see that almost 1/2 of all ads are listed for over $25,000 or that there are more listed for over $30,000 than there are below $1,000.
not the most flattering of reviews when the only positives come on the buying side and seem to rely on the seller not knowing what they are listing.
its always easier to sell someone by telling them what they want to hear than to tell them the truth thats for sure!
I so agree with both of your points above and I have reached out to purchase weeks they have had on their site for over 2+ years, I make an offer they tell me they will get back to me and never do, I tried twice to purchase units that they have for sale and a few months back when yet another agent from their company called me, I told him he has had this ad up for 2+ years and I do not believe that he actually has the ability to sell this unit, as when I make an offer your company ghosts me, or try and call me 6 months later with a resort I did not place an offer on... I personally think they are a horrible company with zero customer service.It's a listing company. They don't sell anything other than take your money to list the timeshare for sale. If you are buying, they will hit you with high closing costs.
That doesnt address that the owner is still being misled as to the actual resale value of their timeshare as part of the "pitch"
Id have no disagreement at all with upfront fee resale companies if their pitch was "you will be lucky to give this away for free, even if you offer to pay closing costs".... vs implying the owner can pay for their premium services and get that or even more money back when it sells knowing full well it wont.
SMTN is just a timeshare listing website that collects a high upfront fee from an owner to slap a listing on their website. They do no vetting of the list price and don't care because they get their fee at time of listing. They aren't as concerned if it sells. They charge high closing costs to the buyer which also drives away potential purchasers. Many of those weeks have been on the site for years. Look at listing on Redweek or the TUG Marketplace.I'm going to sell a couple deeds from Westin Ka'anapali Villas North (KORN). Of course, I intend to list on TUG. But I want to list on other sites too. I looked on SMTN, and they have over 150 units listed from KORN. I can't believe that these are all current. Most are WAY over priced, but a few look like bargains. Any insight on whether all these SMTN listings are legit or are they just listing a few units at a variety of price points? Has anyone bought a Westin Villas deed through SMTN?
I spoke to them as we are looking to retire and for health reasons, I may not be able to travel. They said "The average price range for Marriott Vacation Club Destinations points is $7 to $10 per annual point and the Ko Olina biennial odd year float week mountain view range is $14,900 to $18,000. Attached is the info they provide. Anyme with specific complaints about them?I am not sure of the legality, but SMTN is in fact providing advice on pricing. SMTN's website includes a section called "What's my timeshare worth?". You fill in your resort information and on the last step you are required to enter your name, email and phone number. When you submit, you get this:
"Your ownership information was received and has been assigned to one of our Timeshare Resale Specialists for immediate review. We are analyzing current asking prices in our marketplace for similar properties, as well as other market data, in order to compile your market value survey.
We will contact you shortly to review the Market Value Survey for your specific property."
As they are using existing asking prices in their market value "analysis", I wonder how much the SMTN ad shown below is going to impact their analysis. SMTN, and all other listing companies for that matter, know that if timeshare owners think that their timeshare is worth thousands of dollars it makes it easier for them to close the deal on the upfront fee.
View attachment 91354
Edited: Just for fun, I looked at all the timeshares for sale on SMTN's website.
2,767 total for sale
777 are < $1,000 (28%)
1,291 are $25,000+ (47%)
849 are $30,000+ (31%)
112 are $150,000+ (4%)
I was surprised to see 28% below $1,000. I suspect that many of these may be desperate owners who have dropped their listing prices after getting no inquiries. I am not really surprised to see that almost 1/2 of all ads are listed for over $25,000 or that there are more listed for over $30,000 than there are below $1,000.