Are unassisted and assisted in the same complex? Could he perhaps go into unassisted for awhile, then move up to assisted later?
I was in this spot with my father in law 3 years ago. Once he was diagnosed to require assisted care, no doctor was willing to step up and say that he could get by with unassisted.
I have no idea whether they were correct or not. Once he went into assisted living, we took him on outings twice each week until he told us that we were wearing him out. Once we stopped taking him out, he went downhill really quickly.
I know NOTHING about medicine, but I want to share an observation that I made. It appeared to me that once he was moved into assisted living, my father in law's hydration was inadequate. Because he had to have all of his liquids thickened due to problems swallowing, he did not have open access to water. And without the water, he seemed subject to urinary tract infections. And the UTIs seemed to cause an increase in dementia.
It became a terribly vicious cycle.
Ellen, my heart goes out to you going through this process. I went through it with my mother who became disabled in her mid 50s (and took her own life at 63 because she absolutely refused to be a burden to us), then my mother in law, then my father in law.
Last Spring, my dad had a stroke and I left for Oregon immediately. He has largely recovered. He now needs to use a walker. And he cries very easily. This is a shocking transition for me - my dad was an all-state athlete in both basketball and football - and to see my big, strong daddy shrinking and getting feeble is heart-breaking.
The one thing about the transition is it does help to prepare you for being without them. It was so shocking to lose my mother - she could not get around, but her mind was fully intact - she just was fiercely independent. And such a relief for my mother in law and father in law to be out of their pain.
The whole process is painful.
elaine