... The Ridge is one of the best run resorts and run way better than most big name resorts. Always updating and plans two years out for different buildings.
As a Ridge Tahoe owner from 1994 to 2011, I would completely agree that the Ridge Tahoe is "one of the best run resorts." For (any) timeshare resale value, though, this has no bearing, because it is all about 1) location, 2) supply and demand, and 3) Maintenance Fees.
There is a never-ending supply of Ridge Tahoe units -- most buyers don't know the differences in the buildings, they just see the sales prices, and the OP is well aware that the ongoing cost of a TS is in the yearly MFs.
We signed-over our EOY Plaza unit for free to friends who we knew could afford the MF. Because I knew what it was worth, even at $1.00, I did not want to overcharge them.
I have stated this many times that best time and place to sell is when your up there. We sold our summer Naegle in 2011 to a Tower owner who wanted the Naegle summer for $2500. We sold our Tower unit odd year from a conversation on the Tower elevator Aug 2012 for $2000 and we sold our Tower even year last month for $1500 to a family staying there that read my post trying to help others with information on the Ridge. All three buyers also buying our unit kept our July 4th week we had booked every year. Something you wouldn't get buying points. Also the Ridge helped us with all the buyers saving them money Ridge did paper work for us and our total fee's were aprox $70. and the buyers transfer fee's were aprox $25.00- $30.00 total.
You have a gift for sales and were fortunate to have just what your buyers were looking for. Maybe the OP can get lucky, too. For $100, it is worth it to have the RT handle the paperwork.
What you most likely will find on E-bay are the Naegle blue weeks or the Terrace building or the Casecade . You can find some good deals on the Plaza which is one of the better buildings but down the hill and smaller like the Terrace. Casecade the newest and largest but down at the bottom of the hill behind the Terrace looking at the ski parking lot area.
You also can get a deal zero -$1000 on most of the resorts across from the Ridge that you drive by to go into the Ridge. These are resorts that let owners have day usage at the Ridge.
The "off-site" units associated with the Ridge Tahoe are to be avoided. For someone interested in the RT, they should buy at the Ridge Tahoe and even there, the Cascade and Terrace buildings should be avoided due to a lack of any sort of view.
A patient buyer can get a great deal; here are some completed EBay auctions:
2 BR Plaza
Prime Winter and Summer EOY,
$1.00 including closing costs http://www.ebay.com/itm/THE-RIDGE-T...21258839868?pt=Timeshares&hash=item33840df73c
2 BR Plaza Prime Winter and Summer Every Year, $99.00 +$385 closing costs (no bids, maybe make an offer directly to the EBay seller)
http://www.ebay.com/itm/2BR-THE-RID...90618452863?pt=Timeshares&hash=item5af2ac937f
9,700 Ridge Tahoe Points, $5.00 +$385 closing costs
http://www.ebay.com/itm/9-700-RIDGE...31007155596?pt=Timeshares&hash=item35c919758c
2 BR Tower Swing Season, $5.00 +$385 closing costs
http://www.ebay.com/itm/2BR-THE-RID...90613819913?pt=Timeshares&hash=item5af265e209
2 BR Naegle Prime Summer EOY,
$1.00 including closing costs http://www.ebay.com/itm/The-Ridge-T...60678649911?pt=Timeshares&hash=item53fa1f7037
The OP's question seemed to be, "Is a Naegle building unit worth more than other units at The Ridge Tahoe?" The answer is, "Maybe, if the right buyer can be found." If a quick sale is desired, then probably not.