We thought Sam Sneads (right in Shawnee - next to Playhouse & General Store) was pretty good, and fair pricing. Lunch is not expensive, and you might try there.
But I think I saw another tugger think it wasn't that great.
One day we drove to the Fernwood area, and tried an Italian place, with big signage. Folks there were great (service), nice & clean, but the cook didn't do such a good job......medicore that eve.
Last years ent book had many places, but if not a local, you would have been hard pressed (and take all day) to find many of the places.
The three Shawnee Inn restaurants WERE LISTED, but we didn't get to any of them. I know they had a flood a few months earlier (Del River overflow from Ivan) and it looked like they were still trying to get the Inn back into shape.
(I think they are always working on that place...)
Are you in the Ridge Top or Ridge Top Summit units? Summit are still 5 star.