• The TUGBBS forums are completely free and open to the public and exist as the absolute best place for owners to get help and advice about their timeshares for more than 30 years!

    Join Tens of Thousands of other Owners just like you here to get any and all Timeshare questions answered 24 hours a day!
  • TUG started 31 years ago in October 1993 as a group of regular Timeshare owners just like you!

    Read about our 31st anniversary: Happy 31st Birthday TUG!
  • TUG has a YouTube Channel to produce weekly short informative videos on popular Timeshare topics!

    Free memberships for every 50 subscribers!

    Visit TUG on Youtube!
  • TUG has now saved timeshare owners more than $23,000,000 dollars just by finding us in time to rescind a new Timeshare purchase! A truly incredible milestone!

    Read more here: TUG saves owners more than $23 Million dollars
  • Sign up to get the TUG Newsletter for free!

    Tens of thousands of subscribing owners! A weekly recap of the best Timeshare resort reviews and the most popular topics discussed by owners!
  • Our official "end my sales presentation early" T-shirts are available again! Also come with the option for a free membership extension with purchase to offset the cost!

    All T-shirt options here!
  • A few of the most common links here on the forums for newbies and guests!

Please post Starwood ROFR transactions here (ONLY)

rickandcindy23 said:
Yes, but that is a simple communication issue. We didn't deed our Westins under the kids' names, but if they want to own the weeks after we are done with them or we die, the kids should think it is worthy of that communication.
Click to expand...
Sorry, I was replying to the post you replied to

It sounded like they are wanting to add their names to.some third parties deed, and then the third party drops off the deed. In essence, a sale.

For certain relationships between the original.and new people, like what you mention, the developer rights come across. But I'm pretty sure you have to inform Vistana to do this.

Just modifying the deed (twice) shouldn't work...
 
YYJMSP said:
Sorry, I was replying to the post you replied to

It sounded like they are wanting to add their names to.some third parties deed, and then the third party drops off the deed. In essence, a sale.

For certain relationships between the original.and new people, like what you mention, the developer rights come across. But I'm pretty sure you have to inform Vistana to do this.

Just modifying the deed (twice) shouldn't work...
Click to expand...
I'm in the process of adding our names to our friends deed, they are getting old and not using it much.
We will leave their names on it for few 6 months or may be a year or so.

Question: If i make myself the primary account holder, will this show up under my dashboard ? I have my doubts since it's not all the same names, my existing one is myself and wife only?

If it becomes a resale or not we will find out when we remove their names.
 
babamike said:
I'm in the process of adding our names to our friends deed, they are getting old and not using it much.
We will leave their names on it for few 6 months or may be a year or so.

Question: If i make myself the primary account holder, will this show up under my dashboard ? I have my doubts since it's not all the same names, my existing one is myself and wife only?

If it becomes a resale or not we will find out when we remove their names.
Click to expand...
You will probably need a new login ID.
 
babamike said:
I'm in the process of adding our names to our friends deed, they are getting old and not using it much.
We will leave their names on it for few 6 months or may be a year or so.

Question: If i make myself the primary account holder, will this show up under my dashboard ? I have my doubts since it's not all the same names, my existing one is myself and wife only?

If it becomes a resale or not we will find out when we remove their names.
Click to expand...

Not to sound like a broken record, how would Vistana know there was any change to the deed unless you tell them, and then they would potentially deem this as a resale since the new people on the deed are not in that restricted set of relations that would keep the benefits?

If this worked it would be a massive loophole, and I'm pretty sure it won't work since you have to tell Vistana...
 
YYJMSP said:
Not to sound like a broken record, how would Vistana know there was any change to the deed unless you tell them, and then they would potentially deem this as a resale since the new people on the deed are not in that restricted set of relations that would keep the benefits?

If this worked it would be a massive loophole, and I'm pretty sure it won't work since you have to tell Vistana...
Click to expand...
There are two parts to transferring a timeshare deed.

Changing the legal ownership is easy, you can add or subtract names from the deed, or record a sale or quitclaim deed to another party. Presto, the legal ownership has changed. MVC/Vistana doesn't have to approve and probably doesn't even know about it.

But the second part is getting the developer (MVC/Vistana) on board with the changes you have made. Just because you've changed the legal ownership, doesn't give the new owners any rights to use the Vistana reservations system or other tools. And I suspect that transferring legal ownership without notifying the developer probably violates the terms of the deed restrictions you are legally on the hook to comply with. So your clever workaround is not going to get you anywhere when you actually try to use the ownership. Vistana/MVC is not going to recognize the usage rights of the new owners, and I'm certain they would look at this as a resale.

But I don't know what they'd do if the sale/transfer had already occurred. I suppose they could sue the seller for violating the contract/deed terms and not giving them ROFR, or charge the new owner a hefty fee to be able to use what they own, or... I don't know what other remedies they might have. But I'm sure that people have tried to pull this and my expectation is that it doesn't end well. I'd love to hear from someone who had done this.
 
WKORVN
6k EOYO
Resort view
Platinum
Waived 7/23/24
Week 02

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
 
Last edited:
LoogieMeister said:
WKORVN
6k EOYO
Island view
Platinum
Waived 7/23/24


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
Click to expand...
They don't seem to like reacquiring EOY ownerships, or is that just my incorrect impression?

I wonder if they can only add full EY weeks to the trust (Abound Trust, Flex Trust, whichever) and so buying an EOY gives them a "broken week" that they can't do anything with other than try to resell in its current form? I'm thinking they'd need to own both "halves" (even and odd) of the SAME deeded week to put it into one of the trusts, and it is really unlikely they'd get both halves. Does anyone know if that's true?

Does this same issue exist for ownerships which only consist of one half of the lockoff or the other? IIRC they did sell 1 br and studio weeks back in the day.
 
daviator said:
There are two parts to transferring a timeshare deed.

Changing the legal ownership is easy, you can add or subtract names from the deed, or record a sale or quitclaim deed to another party. Presto, the legal ownership has changed. MVC/Vistana doesn't have to approve and probably doesn't even know about it.

But the second part is getting the developer (MVC/Vistana) on board with the changes you have made. Just because you've changed the legal ownership, doesn't give the new owners any rights to use the Vistana reservations system or other tools. And I suspect that transferring legal ownership without notifying the developer probably violates the terms of the deed restrictions you are legally on the hook to comply with. So your clever workaround is not going to get you anywhere when you actually try to use the ownership. Vistana/MVC is not going to recognize the usage rights of the new owners, and I'm certain they would look at this as a resale.

But I don't know what they'd do if the sale/transfer had already occurred. I suppose they could sue the seller for violating the contract/deed terms and not giving them ROFR, or charge the new owner a hefty fee to be able to use what they own, or... I don't know what other remedies they might have. But I'm sure that people have tried to pull this and my expectation is that it doesn't end well. I'd love to hear from someone who had done this.
Click to expand...
Thanks, I have decided not to proceed with this I don’t want any issues and deal with uncertainties in the future.
 
We passed on an oceanfront Center, Westin south, deeded week 10, which is reserved for us each year, $34K through Redweek.
 
WKORVN OF 2bed EOY
10,000 waived 2/25
Though I don’t believe Marriott has any interest in these EOY contracts, which just makes life simpler.

(Though on the spelling side I have had DVC buy it out and send me a check within a couple days, so all a matter of perspective.)
 
03/03/2024 WKORV North 2 Bedroom Lockoff Oceanfront $32,000. Passed

Sorry, this is a little late. I find the Fail and Passed very confusing but was told Fails means the holder of the right (Vistana/Marriott) exercised their right and purchased it. If it Passes, the holder of the right (Vistana/Marriott) declines to exercise their right, or does not buy it.
 
pipercub said:
03/03/2024 WKORV North 2 Bedroom Lockoff Oceanfront $32,000. Passed

Sorry, this is a little late. I find the Fail and Passed very confusing but was told Fails means the holder of the right (Vistana/Marriott) exercised their right and purchased it. If it Passes, the holder of the right (Vistana/Marriott) declines to exercise their right, or does not buy it.
Click to expand...
You had it right. I asked about this Pass/Fail in the Marriott forum a while back and never really got a consensus on how to change it.
tugbbs.com

ROFR.net Passed/Failed Explanation

This question gets emailed to me from time to time regarding the ROFR database at rofr.net. There seems to be some confusion around the result column in the database and what Passed/Failed really means. I've had about a dozen emails over the years seeking clarification but have had several in...
tugbbs.com tugbbs.com
 
pipercub said:
03/03/2024 WKORV North 2 Bedroom Lockoff Oceanfront $32,000. Passed

Sorry, this is a little late. I find the Fail and Passed very confusing but was told Fails means the holder of the right (Vistana/Marriott) exercised their right and purchased it. If it Passes, the holder of the right (Vistana/Marriott) declines to exercise their right, or does not buy it.
Click to expand...
Suprised you bought at that price.
 
What’s the ROFR that will pass for WKORV Wk 1-50 2 Bd Annual? Friend is selling me his week for 9K. Worried that it might not go through.
 
CaliJoe said:
What’s the ROFR that will pass for WKORV Wk 1-50 2 Bd Annual? Friend is selling me his week for 9K. Worried that it might not go through.
Click to expand...
What is the view?
 
Such a bargain for $9K. I would do it. Rick wouldn't.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top