Is your Rewards No. on your credit card? If so, there's no reason the person checking you in should be able to say they don't have your no. I would call Rewards again and ask to talk to a Supervisor to get those nights credited.
Recently I was at a Courtyard in NC. When I checked in the desk agent didn't offer me a Platinum upgrade. When I questioned her about it she said she didn't have my rewards no. to know I was platinum. I handed her back my credit card and asked her what she saw. She looked at it rather confused and I told her my no. was right below my name. Now, for the rest of the story. . .she was new and this was a priceline reservation, hence, no rewards no. with reservationist. I didn't push the hotel for the $100 compensation for not recognizing the platinum status.
Recently I was at a Courtyard in NC. When I checked in the desk agent didn't offer me a Platinum upgrade. When I questioned her about it she said she didn't have my rewards no. to know I was platinum. I handed her back my credit card and asked her what she saw. She looked at it rather confused and I told her my no. was right below my name. Now, for the rest of the story. . .she was new and this was a priceline reservation, hence, no rewards no. with reservationist. I didn't push the hotel for the $100 compensation for not recognizing the platinum status.
Terry
This is not necessilary true. In the summer of 2010 I traded into Newport Coast and at check-in I handed over my Marriott CC. During my stay, I, as I often do, had several drinks at the pool bar charged to the room. I didn't think anything of it until I got home and checked my rewards account. No Credit for my stay?!!! Apparently the associate at check in neglected to add my rewards # and they would not credit me the nights despite my protest.
Tough lesson to learn!
From then on I always call the resort prior to my trip, check my account for upcomming reservations prior to leaving and I ALWAYS , ALWAYS make it a point to see that the associate at check-in has my rewards # on the reservation.