I own at Little Bay and have visited the island more than 20 times. Have never stayed at Oyster Bay but have driven through the area often. We like the location of Divi and enjoy its nice beach and decent access to restaurants and other beaches around the island. For us, the Oyster Bay Area is nice but not as convenient if you want to explore the island, like we always want to do. (Don't do the AI…Divi restaurants are just ok, and far from the quality of dining at local restaurants.)