- Joined
- Jun 6, 2005
- Messages
- 5,021
- Reaction score
- 4,736
- Resorts Owned
- Marriott:
Maui Ocean Club
Waiohai Beach Club
Barony Beach Club
Abound ClubPoints
HGVC:
HGVC at Sea World
Putting that aside, for those of you who have visited this Resort. How does it compare to other accommodations in the area? I looked into it for a bit last year, and it felt very secluded and lacking amenities. Curious what everyone's thoughts are.
i'd think being secluded means it's better for staying at the resort, and not so good as a hub. that's my hangup about booking - that it's not actually at anywhere we want to see (Florence for example). that, and the fact that suddenly it's gotten very hard to book and you have to walk for months to get anything in the summer.
It depends on what you are looking for and what you want to see. If Florence is your primary goal, book a nice hotel in Florence. We spent five nights there at the Westin Excelsior during our trip last summer after our week at the Borgo. We loved Borgo alle Vigne because it wasn't in the city and we wanted to experience the wineries in the Tuscan countryside, but there were also a few sights we wanted to see in Florence. Additionally, it was easier to get group tours from Florence to some areas of Tuscany with other great wineries like Montalcino and Montepulciano. Those villages are a longer drive from the Borgo.
Borgo is a great location for visiting the many wineries and hilltop villages in that part of Tuscany. There must be a dozen or more small wineries within a 5 to 10 minute drive of Borgo. Visiting wineries was our main activity during our week. The small villages in the area like Peccioli, Selvatelle, and Capannoli all have excellent small restaurants with fine-dining quality without fine dining prices. Great local wines can be had for just €10-€15 per bottle in restaurants. Sangiovese is the local varietal, but you can also get Cabernets, Merlots, blends, and white wines. The hilltop villages of Volterra and San Gimignano are not far away and private (and some group) tours can be booked though vendors the staff at Borgo can refer you to. A day trip to Pisa or Lucca is also doable.
As far as other accommodations in the immediate area, I did not really see many. I'm sure there are some AirBnBs in the area, there is a small modern local hotel in a newer area of Peccioli, and Italy has a concept called Agritourismo where you stay in a BnB on a farm, but Borgo is not in a big tourist area with lots of other hotels/resorts. Its appeal is as a way to see what life is sort of like in rural Tuscany while staying at a property with HGVC brand-standard quality rather than an unpredictable AirBnB or Agritourismo.
If you want or are expecting a typical European city experience, or a typical HGVC resort experience with lots of on-site activities, you may want to go elsewhere.