I didn’t share an opinion. Is asked a question that seemed like a logical one to ask given the OP’s past comments about Wyndham.
You had to have seen my answer.
1) Wyndham controls fees and manages the resorts well. On the resort level, I have no complaints, really. Just have a problem with CORPORATE, specifically Michael Brown.
2) I have a LOT of Wyndham points to use that don't get used right now, but I would use them for Maui. Would be the ideal.
3) I could avoid using RCI with leftover points. $299 exchange fees/ Diamond and Hilton add-on fees.
4) I would be able to book our home resort weeks ahead of anyone with our Hawaii home resort priority (or whatever it's called), so could likely get the oceanfront units with points. Even if the points were 500,000 for each Oceanfront week, it would be getting rid of Hono Koa $3,000 MF's and using Wyndham points we already own to book. Might even cost me a little more through Wyndham, depending on the points required.
5) Wyndham needs Maui. They have all of the other islands covered. Lots on BI, Kauai has a bunch, Oahu has 3 now with the Shell Waikiki Marina, and nothing at all on Maui.
Ironically, the first Wyndham timeshare presentation we attended was on Maui. They were selling the other islands but talked up Outrigger Club, which we cannot book anymore, not that we ever thought it was a good deal.
We absolutely love Shearwater and would love to stay there with the kids and grandkids sometime. We will do our best to do that at some point in the future. That would use a lot of points. Two of our kids always seems to have plans to go to Europe, our son likes for us to tag along to help with the little twins. Our oldest son, daughter-in-law and two grandkids go to Hawaii a lot with her parents, since they own Marriott Abound.