We've done the kayak trip several times so this past summer, we tried the hike down the hill from above. I found it an interesting alternative. We encountered another couple doing the same thing. It think it is faster too, certainly considering the time you spent renting a kayak, unloading it at the water, and paddling over to the monument. If I had never done either I'd probably do the kayak trip. The hike isn't better than than the kayak, just a different experience. Note that it is a pretty steep climb back up. We are in pretty good shape so it wasn't that challenging. If you aren't it good shape, I'd bypass this adventure.