I wanted to get the Amex Platinum, but the fee is so high that it's hard to justify.
I normally travel internationally a lot but the last two years, none, so it has been harder to justify. I already have global entry and TSA PreCheck, don't use the credits for exercise or media/streaming since it is now only 4 options that we don't use. In the past they provided streaming credits period, it didn't matter what, so I used those (netflix, YouTube TV, etc). You get a $50 credit at Saks Fifth Avenue so my wife buys a $50ish thing every 6 months since it is free. We used the lounges a lot and when my family would travel with me, it justified the $175 extra for them to have it also but when the traveling stopped, it didn't so back to the free Gold for them.
The first year that I got it, I had just gotten a new phone and was in Barcelona where my phone was stolen in the metro. I had to get a police report and fill out their form but then they reimbursed the full price of the phone since I bought it on the card. That alone paid for more than that year's fee. Then a couple years later we had ordered a light from Morocco and it showed up dented. The company in Fez blamed FedEx, FedEx wouldn't take the blame, so I turned to Amex and they reimbursed me the cost which again was more than the annual fee. Between these incidents, the little credits here and there for stuff like Home Depot, Best Buy, Saks, streaming, now Walmart +, gold status for HH, Uber and Uber Eats credits, hotel credits, airline credits, etc., I have been able to get more out of it than I paid in the fee but the last couple of years I have had to work at it more.
I will say that I just booked HGV lodging in April for Hawaii and the card credited the $59 reservation fee and the $69 trip protection. I don't normally get the trip protection but who knows what will be happening in April so I got it this time and they ended up being free with the credit plus I booked my flights via the amex travel service where you get 5% back and it credited some for the cost of the flights. This year I have gotten $1,551.53 in statements credits so far, so more than the annual fee but again, I have had to try to use the benefits more than previous years when they just happened with travel. It is an expensive card and we do use the benefits but you have to be intentional, like buying the phone with the amex for the purchase protection or using Walmart +, which we had never done, but it is nice to get a quick delivery of items from there. Now if they would start delivering beer through it.....we would be set.......