• Welcome to the FREE TUGBBS forums! The absolute best place for owners to get help and advice about their timeshares for more than 32 years!

    Join Tens of Thousands of other owners just like you here to get any and all Timeshare questions answered 24 hours a day!
  • TUG started 32 years ago in October 1993 as a group of regular Timeshare owners just like you!

    Read about our 32nd anniversary: Happy 32nd Birthday TUG!
  • TUG has a YouTube Channel to produce weekly short informative videos on popular Timeshare topics!

    All subscribers auto-entered to win all free TUG membership giveaways!

    Visit TUG on Youtube!
  • TUG has now saved timeshare owners more than $24,000,000 dollars just by finding us in time to rescind a new Timeshare purchase! A truly incredible milestone!

    Read more here: TUG saves owners more than $24 Million dollars
  • Wish you could meet up with other TUG members? Well look no further as this annual event has been going on for years in Orlando! How to Attend the TUG January Get-Together!
  • Now through the end of the year you can join or renew your TUG membership at the lowest price ever offered! Learn More!
  • Sign up to get the TUG Newsletter for free!

    Tens of thousands of subscribing owners! A weekly recap of the best Timeshare resort reviews and the most popular topics discussed by owners!
  • Our official "end my sales presentation early" T-shirts are available again! Also come with the option for a free membership extension with purchase to offset the cost!

    All T-shirt options here!
  • A few of the most common links here on the forums for newbies and guests!

HI Car Rental Recommendations

Looks like KOA Alamo does NOT have a 'Skip the counter' :-(
Did the Accelerated check-in. Will see how long it takes tmrw...
Mahalo!

1757248172643.png
 
I've used National exclusively for more years than I can remember. Every single time, the price has been lower than other companies (including Costco)
We love National but pricing has always been higher than Costco Alamo, every time I have checked. For tmrw's pickup, rate is almost double for National vs Alamo for me (800+ vs 400+)... Love National but don't like their prices, hence do Alamo (same Co, similar service, cheaper price, inn my experience)...
 
Looks like KOA Alamo does NOT have a 'Skip the counter' :-(
Did the Accelerated check-in. Will see how long it takes tmrw...

Exactly the same amount of time it would have taken without it.

There are typically only a couple clerks at the counter. All the flights arrive in waves. (You can verify this on flightaware.) So all the tourists arrive in waves. And nearly all tourists march lockstep. So they all arrive at the rental counters in waves.

If only one of you is driving, go get the rental car first (while everyone else is lockstep, waiting for their bags). And then park in the cell phone lot, until someone in your party calls to let you know the bags can be loaded. While they're 20-deep in line at Alamo, you're already on the ring road. If you skip Costco you'll save even more time -- and the quality of your vacation will skyrocket. (Costco is the rookie mistake tourists make until they learn where the good food can be found.)
 
go get the rental car first (while everyone else is lockstep, waiting for their bags). And then park in the cell phone lot, until someone in your party calls to let you know the bags can be loaded.
Love it!
Mahalo!
 
I get a good corporate with Hertz as a retiree benefit, but sometimes Autoslash beats it. This year at KOA it was Alamo/Budget and we do as Skoop suggested, I run to get the car. The CS was not too bad, I'm used to the upsell BS, they end up giving me the car they tried to upsell, Nissan Maxima. Not a bad car, but the maintenance reminder kept coming on...

Funny thing happened, a couple ahead of me loaded up the wrong vehicle, then he came back in all pissed because the key wouldn't work. The CS guy stepped outside and hit the panic button on the remote so his car lit up and honked - oops, let me switch my bags over there...

We used Hertz for a day rental in Waikiki because the drop off is right across from Hokulani where we stayed. Pickup was a disaster, a long line of Japanese tourists and only 1 CS rep. I don't recommend Waikiki Hertz!
 
We love National but pricing has always been higher than Costco Alamo, every time I have checked. For tmrw's pickup, rate is almost double for National vs Alamo for me (800+ vs 400+)... Love National but don't like their prices, hence do Alamo (same Co, similar service, cheaper price, inn my experience)...
It must be the dates I need a rental. One thing to watch out for: If you have Emerald Executive status (I have it from an Amex card), the price is always higher than regular Emerald status, so you need to uncheck that.
 
If you have Emerald Executive status (I have it from an Amex card), the price is always higher than regular Emerald status, so you need to uncheck that.
Yup; already did that...
Know they are sneaky this way...
Have done tons of rentals & was the same for me every time, so got into the CSTCO---> Alamo routine...
 
Alamo/Budget and we do as Skoop suggested, I run to get the car. The CS was not too bad, I'm used to the upsell BS, they end up giving me the car they tried to upsell, Nissan Maxima. Not a bad car, but the maintenance reminder kept coming on...
? Avis/Budget
(Alamo is National/Enterprise)...
 
Alamo is usually PYO (pick your own) vehicle in the class, so usually no fuss about a particular car, can just see whatever seems better/newer/lower mi etc. Most are recent models with low mileage (although haven't rented in HI for a bit, so will find out soon)..
Mahalo!
 
@JohnnyO & others, which car rental do you recommend at KOA (or OGG)?
Dollar/Thrifty have excellent rates but worried about the silly AI automated junk charges Hertz is pushing on people these days + not-so-nice CS with them. Have always loved Alamo/National but rates a bit higher. Thoughts?
Mahalo!
We always go with locally owned rental car companies. The cars are a little older but it's way cheaper and you are supporting local business.
 
We always go with locally owned rental car companies. The cars are a little older but it's way cheaper and you are supporting local business.
You do know that even the big car rental chains are local business? They employ locals, pay taxes to the state, etc.
 
You do know that even the big car rental chains are local business? They employ locals, pay taxes to the state, etc.
I think they are talking about locals owning the business, not just working there.
 
I think they are talking about locals owning the business, not just working there.
They probably were. But I just wanted to point out that companies like Avis, and the other car companies, are a part of the Hawaiian economy. It's nice to frequent locally owned businesses when possible, but don't forget that the Avises (and others) are contributing to the local economy through wages paid to employees, local taxes, and partnerships with local businesses.
 
They probably were. But I just wanted to point out that companies like Avis, and the other car companies, are a part of the Hawaiian economy. It's nice to frequent locally owned businesses when possible, but don't forget that the Avises (and others) are contributing to the local economy through wages paid to employees, local taxes, and partnerships with local businesses.
Of course they do, but so do the truly locally owned businesses, and pretty much all businesses operating there. The differentiation is where the profits go. The true locally owned businesses are more likely to keep them in HI, adding even more to the economy.
 
Of course they do, but so do the truly locally owned businesses, and pretty much all businesses operating there. The differentiation is where the profits go. The true locally owned businesses are more likely to keep them in HI, adding even more to the economy.
To carry this one step further does that mean you (and that is the universal you) don't frequent any of the businesses that aren't local to Hawaii? The hotel and restaurant chains? I should have addressed this to @triangulum33 . When we visit we spend our money at both locally owned and non locally owned businesses. Both support the local economy.

I have looked at some of the locally owned car rental agencies. They never seem to have what we need for our trips. One trip my brother in law rented from a local agency. I don't know whether it was to save money or support local, but the car was a joke. He had to go out and start it up, let it run for awhile before they could do anywhere. And when he tried to adjust the rear view mirror it fell off in his hand. Kind of scared us away from renting from that type of operation.
 
To carry this one step further does that mean you (and that is the universal you) don't frequent any of the businesses that aren't local to Hawaii? The hotel and restaurant chains? I should have addressed this to @triangulum33 . When we visit we spend our money at both locally owned and non locally owned businesses. Both support the local economy.

I have looked at some of the locally owned car rental agencies. They never seem to have what we need for our trips. One trip my brother in law rented from a local agency. I don't know whether it was to save money or support local, but the car was a joke. He had to go out and start it up, let it run for awhile before they could do anywhere. And when he tried to adjust the rear view mirror it fell off in his hand. Kind of scared us away from renting from that type of operation.
No, but as you note it was @triangulum33's point not mine. We did try a local outfit for car rental on Maui and the car lived up to the name of the business, it was a real wreck.

We do often patronize locally owned businesses when we travel, but not always. We weigh all the various factors and make a choice. I am unaware of any locally owned timeshares but maybe they exist.
 
No, but as you note it was @triangulum33's point not mine. We did try a local outfit for car rental on Maui and the car lived up to the name of the business, it was a real wreck.

We do often patronize locally owned businesses when we travel, but not always. We weigh all the various factors and make a choice. I am unaware of any locally owned timeshares but maybe they exist.
Must be the same company my brother in law used. :D
 
@Luanne , I was trying to make a point that we like to patronize the locally owned car rental agencies. Of course the chains hire local folks to work there, and I wasn't trying to disparage them at all. The two companies we have rented from have different choices of how "seasoned" of a car you rent. Personally, I'm fine with a 5yo car if I can save 50% over the chains. I also like how easy it is to pick up and drop off the car in the parking lot directly across from the terminals.
But do whatever floats yer boat.
 
triangulum33, do you have local companies in Maui that you like?
 
If you are a Costco member, their car rates are very difficult to beat. They use Avis, National, Enterprise and Budget and you get an additional driver as well.

Except when they're renting out phantom cars Christmas week and Ironman. Costco assumes we have an unlimited supply of rental vehicles. And they "write checks the rental companies can't cash."


Every year, it's a game of musical chairs. And the people without a chair when the music stops have to rent Uhauls and even panel trucks to get around. Happens every year.

Like most other things they do, Costco is convenient -- not particularly good.

I know a private chef whose gazillionaire clients bought a car Christmas week because they couldn't rent one. After they were done, they sold it back to the dealership and took the depreciation hit.


Car salesman: "What kind of car are you looking for today?"


Visitor: "The kind I can be driving in less than 30 minutes. Chop chop."
 
Except when they're renting out phantom cars Christmas week and Ironman. Costco assumes we have an unlimited supply of rental vehicles. And they "write checks the rental companies can't cash."


Every year, it's a game of musical chairs. And the people without a chair when the music stops have to rent Uhauls and even panel trucks to get around. Happens every year.

Like most other things they do, Costco is convenient -- not particularly good.

I know a private chef whose gazillionaire clients bought a car Christmas week because they couldn't rent one. After they were done, they sold it back to the dealership and took the depreciation hit.


Car salesman: "What kind of car are you looking for today?"


Visitor: "The kind I can be driving in less than 30 minutes. Chop chop."
That is odd, because every time I use Costco car rental, the company instantly gives Costco their reservation number, and I can look it up and add to my account on the car rental company site. Clearly the car rental company is writing the check, not Costco. Sounds like an old wives' tale related to your bitterness toward Costco.
 
every time I use Costco car rental, the company instantly gives Costco their reservation number, and I can look it up and add to my account on the car rental company site. Clearly the car rental company is writing the check, not Costco
+ we can do accelerated check-in &/or skip the counter for many (to skip the lines & faster exit & hopefully greater likelihood of getting a car before the busloads of fellow pax from the flights get their cars)....
(+ COST does show many vehicle categories being unavailable, if they are not available from the rental agency).
It is possible during super-peak times, rental agencies overbook (as they know many noshows etc) but some may be left holding the bag.
Agree, rental agency issue, not a COST issue but good for folks to know ahead of time, esp if traveling at super-peak times (which we never do)..
 
@Luanne , I was trying to make a point that we like to patronize the locally owned car rental agencies. Of course the chains hire local folks to work there, and I wasn't trying to disparage them at all. The two companies we have rented from have different choices of how "seasoned" of a car you rent. Personally, I'm fine with a 5yo car if I can save 50% over the chains. I also like how easy it is to pick up and drop off the car in the parking lot directly across from the terminals.
But do whatever floats yer boat.
I just checked the rates at Kihei Rent A Car, which is one of the companies that gets mentioned a lot on the Trip Advisor Forum for Maui. Currently my price with Enterprise booked through Costco is less than any of their prices. And for the same size SUV we have rented they want $700 more for the 3 week period we have booked. So no savings. I do keep checking the small local companies but as I stated in an earlier post they have never come in cheaper for the type of car we want. And the smaller sedans with Kihei Rent A Car were all more than what we've booked for an SUV. So booking through Costco floats my boat. :)
 
triangulum33, do you have local companies in Maui that you like?
I have a 12 day midsized car reserved for Thanksgiving from Makoa Rental in Maui for $600. We have used Aloha Maui a couple times and liked them. Some of our past trips we've Uber'd the entire time.
 
Top