Tombo,
If your primary issue is that phase 2 of BRV has Festiva employees on the board, then we can offer to trade your deed for one in phase 1 of BRV, which is an owner-controlled HOA.
I've tried reaching out to you to resolve your issues directly to no avail, and if this is something you are interested in, please contact me directly at
comments@festiva.travel.
Keep in mind that (1) Festiva employees only took places on the board at BRV-2 that were previously occupied by Wyndham when we acquired the resort and (2) the renovations in three buildings in phase 2 have been very well-received by owners and are nearing completion.
I hope to hear from you soon.
The owners have not been polled about whether they like the renovations or not, at least I haven't received any questionnaire asking what I liked and didn't like about the renovations. I also never received a questionnaire, poll, or vote on whether us owners even wanted to renovate, how much renovation if any we wanted, or how much we thought that we should be assessed or have our MF's increased to do any renovations. I am sure that many owners like the renovations (they are very nice), but how many would have voted for the renovations if given the facts, figures, and the chance to vote? Festiva voted to renovate, they voted to raise MF's, they voted to assess, and they voted that the owners pay for the renovations they didn't get to vote on. Remember the tea party? Taxation without representation caused that revolt.
Thanks for the offer but to exchange a Phase 2 unit for a phase one unit just because Festiva took over the Phase 2 board would be a bad trade for me and a good trade for Festiva. The offers I have seen Festiva make so far to owners are always a win for Festiva and a loss for the owners IMO, and this offer to give me a phase 1 week for a Phase 2 week I own is no exception.
Another example of a Festiva win, owner lose offer is when Festiva offers a deeded owner a chance to swap the week he owns and a lot of cash for some points. Here is how this great deal works: Festiva wants to offer owners the chance to give up their deeded weeks that they own free and clear and $3500 of their personal cash for some festiva points which will not sell for $1 on ebay. After an owner accepts Festiva's offer Festiva will own the previous owner's week free and clear, the owner will no longer own anything, the owner will be a member of a "club" for 30 years (or until the club folds), the club member will be responsible for all Maintenance and upkeep on the week that festiva now owns, the club member will now be responsible for all assessments and upgrades that festiva wants to do, and at the end of 30 years the previous owner owns nothing and is no longer even a club member, and Festiva owns the week in perpetuity which has been maintained, upgraded for 30 years by the "member". Top that off with the fact that Festiva puts it's own mgt company in place to run the resort (with no bids on Mgt fees against other mgt companies ever taken) and Festiva gets to charge any Mgt fees they see fit to charge and make even more profit off of the "members" each and every year with no chance for the "members" to throw Festiva out as mgt company and hire a more efficient and fiscally conservative mgt company EVER. It is easy to see that everything about this deal is a win for festiva and a loss for the former owner.
I am sorry, I digressed, so back to your kind offer to me. Phase 2 units are newer than Phase one, and my phase 2 unit is one of the deluxe 2 bed rooms which is over 1400 square feet as opposed to a phase one 2 bed room which is older and smaller (I think about 1300 square feet). To swap to phase one would not make sense because I would be trading a larger newer unit for a smaller older unit. I understand why you would want me to trade, but I refuse to give up something of greater value to get something of lesser value. That would be like giving you a week I own and $3500 for some points. That reminds me of Jack giving up a valuable cow for some worthless magic beans. The beans did actually work in that fairy tale, but I am too old and wise to believe in fairy tales or that Festiva points will get me prime summer or winter weeks each and every year. I do know for sure that my FIXED weeks will get me what I want each and every year, no fairy tales or pixie dust, just pure old deeded ownership.
My primary issue is that Festiva does what it wants and does not care about owners wishes, wants, or needs. Festiva only cares about Festiva and Festiva profit from everything I have seen. Before Festiva came owners could list weeks for sale at the office, since Festiva took over the office said that they are not allowed to tell anyone about any owner weeks for sale anymore. Pre Festiva you could do internal swaps if there was availability, post Festiva the staff told me that they weren't supposed to do internal swaps anymore because Festiva doesn't like it. Pre Festiva the resort did maintenance and upgrades using the reserves from the annual MF's. Post Festiva assessments and MF increases are needed to upgrade and maintain the resort according to Festiva (Wyndham maintained the resort just fine within the buget and MF's we paid). Pre festiva we received detailed annual budgets in the mail each and every year, post Festiva nothing sent to owners showing where our money was spent or where it was going to be spent (Festiva claims that they are a club and not required to give out such things). Pre Festiva the owners had input and votes on expenditures, post festiva we get a bill in the mail. Pre Festiva no expansion plans for new buildings in the woods surrounding our resort, post festiva timeshare cabins in the woods will be built (if Festiva can sell them in this economy), and the new cabins will have access to our pools, lake, and other common areas crowding our existing facilites with no vote from us.
Did festiva take a vote of the owners to see if the majority of owners wanted to upgrade to granite counter tops and other things that aren't needed at a RUSTIC mountain resort? Not a vote, not an informal survey, not anything other than an upgrade plan hatched and implemented by Festiva with little if any owner input. Has Festiva gotten several sealed bids from numerous contractors to do the renovations so the owners can get the best price and to prevent any hint of graft or kickbacks? Nope, Festiva set up a budget and hired contactors without bids as far as us owners know. Did Festiva come in and take over the common areas claiming that festiva not the owners owned them? Yes Festiva did and the phase one board had to hire a lawyer to reclaim our pool, tennis courts, lake, and club house as our own. Even after we got legal counsel to regain control over the common areas that always should have been ours, Festiva still has the whole upstairs of the club house for their sales office and I have never seen anything in writing where Festiva pays the owners rent for using OUR clubhouse.
I do hate that Festiva controls the Phase 2 board, but I hate even more that thanks to Festiva's legal shenanigans that this resort will never be sold out and owner controlled. Festiva will always be involved unless(or until)Festiva goes bankrupt or broke.
It is nice to hear from you again Festiva rep, but I am afraid that I will have to turn down your offer to swap my larger newer unit for an older smaller unit. I also must turn down any offers to swap my prime fixed weeks that I own for some magical points that might or might not get me a prime summer week or a prime ski week in the future. Thanks again but I will pass on all of the Festiva offers I have seen so far.
P.S. While you are making offers, if you would like to offer to remove all Festiva employees from both boards and allow the owners and members who actually pay to maintain and upgrade the resort to be the board members who control the budget and decisions at BRV, that is an offer I will gladly accept.