• Welcome to the FREE TUGBBS forums! The absolute best place for owners to get help and advice about their timeshares for more than 32 years!

    Join Tens of Thousands of other owners just like you here to get any and all Timeshare questions answered 24 hours a day!
  • TUG started 32 years ago in October 1993 as a group of regular Timeshare owners just like you!

    Read about our 32nd anniversary: Happy 32nd Birthday TUG!
  • TUG has a YouTube Channel to produce weekly short informative videos on popular Timeshare topics!

    All subscribers auto-entered to win all free TUG membership giveaways!

    Visit TUG on Youtube!
  • TUG has now saved timeshare owners more than $24,000,000 dollars just by finding us in time to rescind a new Timeshare purchase! A truly incredible milestone!

    Read more here: TUG saves owners more than $24 Million dollars
  • Wish you could meet up with other TUG members? Well look no further as this annual event has been going on for years in Orlando! How to Attend the TUG January Get-Together!
  • Now through the end of the year you can join or renew your TUG membership at the lowest price ever offered! Learn More!
  • Sign up to get the TUG Newsletter for free!

    Tens of thousands of subscribing owners! A weekly recap of the best Timeshare resort reviews and the most popular topics discussed by owners!
  • Our official "end my sales presentation early" T-shirts are available again! Also come with the option for a free membership extension with purchase to offset the cost!

    All T-shirt options here!
  • A few of the most common links here on the forums for newbies and guests!

Exchange vs. Staying where you own

I stay where we own - Massanutten. We live near the water so we appreciate the mountains. Since we are not tied to any work/school schedule we use a lot of last calls to go other places. My husband is self employed, and I can get off just about anytime I want with a few days notice.
 
I only own DVC - Villas at Grand Californian. When we go to Disneyland I want to stay at the Grand Californian and with the incentives they had last summer buying was cheaper than renting from Disney or other DVC owners.

I don't have a ton of points so I expect we'll use the points for the Grand Californian 80% of the time and then once in awhile at DVC resorts at WDW or possibly Hawaii.

I don't anticipate ever using the points for anything other than DVC properties. I'd likely be better off renting the points and then renting another property instead of trading.
 
We own at 3 resorts and tend to stay at least one of them each year and exchange the other(s) throught RCI Points. That way we get the benefit of both going back to somewhere we know well and checking out new places.

Although I enjoy visiting new areas there is a lot to be said for laid back vacations at our own resorts where you don't feel obliged to 'do' all the sights in a week in case you never come back!
 
I've never stayed in four of the units I own. Never even seen one of the resorts. Might finally go there this year.

It has been years since I've stayed in my owned week in another resort.

We stay in the 2br side of our Orlando week 52 lockoff about every other year. I've never seen the 1br side.

Sheila
 
We own 7 timeshare 4 weeks an one resort, and only trade once traded with RCI, in 8 yrs. had 11 for 3yrs never traded with them,we used two of our resort every year both in NY driveing distance, (1 to 2 hrs)
our Carribean resort we go every two years, But we do trade Person To person,We love the sea and sun,goes to the Carribean atleast twice per year thru direct exchange with owners of resort we want to go to in other Countrys,have traded NYC for Half Moon in Jamaica, Marriott St Kitts,
Marriott Spain, and marriott Paris, all direct here on Tug:whoopie:
 
We have actually stayed at one of our resorts. Once. We got an Extra Vacation there for much less than the MF! The rest of the time I've used the RCI Points to get 3+ weeks use from the 1 ownership using 7500 and 9000 point last minute exchanges. Our MROP is a kind of low budget mini group of 50some resorts, so we move around a lot on those. This year, PV and Hawaii, so it isn't all bad.

I'd buy a late summer Yellowstone area fixed week to use if I found one.

So Dave, it looks like you are doing good on saving $358 in exchange fees this year. And from my very loose count, it looks like so far the majority of respondents are exchangers. And that's the cool thing about TS'ing. Flexibility. And that's also what makes the learning curve so steep, and what makes TUG so valuable.

Jim Ricks
 
Last edited:
We exchange 4 of our 5 timeshares most of the time and never exchange one of our timeshares.
 
It has changed for me. I used to exchange most of my weeks, but now I stay at my home resorts most of the time. I rearranged my portfolio so that I own at places that I really enjoy and are also within a reasonable driving distance.

While I'm not completely abandoning exchanging, it is so easy to rent most places that I plan to rent weeks more than exchange when I want additional weeks in the future.

Steve
 
Absolutely, agree and I think that our exchanging vs using may change in the future

Although I enjoy visiting new areas there is a lot to be said for laid back vacations at our own resorts where you don't feel obliged to 'do' all the sights in a week in case you never come back!

Just for that reason. :)
 
Easier for you, being on the West Coast

And that completely explains why you never go back to the same place. Go to Hawaii - you WILL go back! :D


I haven't yet figured out how to manage flights from the East Coast. Flights out West are about as long as I think I can take. I need four weeks. One week to spend on the West Coast pre-Hawaii, two weeks in Hawaii, and a post-Hawaii week on the West Coast before heading back. It will be many years before I can do four or even three weeks together.

But now that the kids no longer are interested in going on vacations with us, I do see Hawaii in our future. I've just got to figure out the best way to deal with those long flights.

But now you're telling me that I'll want to go back over and over :eek:

I better just stay away from that place altogether. :D
 
I studied the timesharing skills from TUG. Attended a TS tour and almost bought a developer unit, came home, on-line searched, found TUG, and cancelled the contract.
I wanted a low MN unit for trade since we want to explore LOTs of places.
Studied for a few months, bought two studio units in South Africa (with 10 yrs RCI membership) when US $= 12 Rand and sold when US dollar exchange value decreased in half.
Studied again with Tuggers' suggestions, bought two studio units in Southern California with MN fee about $350 (current).
We had many good trades through RCI mostly either in July 4 or Christmas-New Year week including: 1bedroom summer Manhattan club, Christmas 2bedroom Orange Lake Orlando, July 4 week Island Park (Yellowstone) and 2 bedroom Jackson Hole, Christmas week 1bedroom Intrawest Palm Spring, summer in Oregon, Birch Bay (WA).
We rented HGVC Waikoloa and Westin Cabo San Lucas when we can't plan in advance and also ran out banked week for exchange.
I exchanged into two DVC weeks for July 4 this year and finally bought HGVC (Flamingo) for their Hawaii locations and RCI point system.

Joining TUG was one of the best investments I had ever made!
 
We bought our first week at Banff in the summer about 6 years ago and have never used our summer week since we have a trailer at a lake about 1.5 hours west of Banff. We have rented it and done exchanges through TUG and exchange companies that don't have annual fees. THen we bought a ski week that we use about half of the time at the same resort. We'll be there next week. We also occasionally use bonus time at this resort. Bought an EOY week in Kelowna with friends and have used it since we owned it but that is only 2 times but have no plans to ever trade it if we can't go our friends will use it or vice versa. Have recently bought Worldmark but I'm still waiting for the account to be transferred and I'm looking forward to using the system. I keep telling myself I don't need any more but who knows this is likely our last year at the lake since the owner is selling the lots for more than we paid for our house.:eek:

Joan
 
In our 23 years of timesharing we have only stayed a full week once at one of our resorts. That was our first week at San Luis Bay Inn, Avila Beach California. We sold that one a couple years ago. Our other resort Gaslamp Plaza Suites San Diego, we bought for trading only as we live only an hour away from it. However we have used bonus time frequently at the Gaslamp for 2-3 night getaways to play tourist in San Diego. We are going to use our week at Gaslamp next year for the July 4th week. I already have it reserved. After that we are going to sell that one too as we prefer non-timeshare trips.

We have stayed in several timeshares more than once, Grand Mayan 5 times, HGVC/Flamingo Las Vegas 5 times, and several others 2 or 3 times. We are off to Hawaii in a couple weeks for 1 week at Kona and 1 week at Waikiki.
 
We never have used our two weeks in Myrtle Beach, but we go look at it when we are going thru the area. We have used those weeks for places we need to fly to, or can't use our motorhome for. We go to Santa Fe every other year for a work conference, and so far have been lucky to get trades. We do the Carribbean every other Dec, and always trade for that. Mexico, Europe, and West Coast, Hawaii, and NYC have been most of our trades.

Being a life long camper, I have really been able to stay in nice, nice places. What a treat.
 
We own several timeshares. When we first bought each one, it was to stay there. But as our life and residences changed over the years, so did the way we use our timeshares. Buddy Dive Bonaire - we stay there every year for 1 - 3 weeks. It's a floating RTU. Celebrity Resorts Orlando - we always exchange because we now live near Orlando. Hatteras High NC - we always exchange because we now live at the beach. Worldmark - we usually use our credits in one or more of the resorts in the Worldmark system (no exchange fees).
 
Curious to know how often you stay where you own, vs. exchanging into another resort somewhere.
Dave

Owners in Sint Maarten since 1985 (3 wks, 2b LO -- stay there every year; exchanged only twice). Our Kids use lockout portion for exchange if we do not take friends/family with us.
 
Curious to know how often you stay where you own, vs. exchanging into another resort somewhere.
In the 20 years we have owned timeshares, we have used the week where we own 39 times and exchanged into another timeshare 27 times. We presently have 2 weeks spacebanked.
 
dvc member

I owned my BWV points since 1997. Went there for upteen number of spring breaks and christmasses/new years. In 2009 used our points to go to Disneyland Paris, an excuse to go to Paris. Using my 2010 points to go to Spain , Club lacosta Marina dorado using RCI exchange. 2011 will be Japan and 2012 will be Hongkong using points. But reading your comments I know I am not doing it right but that's OK.
 
We've stayed in a resort we owned before we owned it and we stayed in a resort we owned after we owned it but we never stayed in a resort we owned while we owned it and we are very happy about that.
 
I'm truly surprised to see how many people are using their timeshares for exchanges, given the dwindling availability of desirable resorts available through RCI.

We began buying weeks (always resale at bargain prices) in the mid 1990's. We exchanged often, approximately 100 times, and have had wonderful vacations all over the U.S., Canada, Caribbean, Mexico, Hawaii, and Europe. Many of these vacations consisted of 4 weeks back-to-back in a specific area.

We live in the New York City area and hate the cold winters. For years we planned to buy a condo in Florida when we retired. We planned to spend about 4-5 winter months there. Many of our relatives and former co-workers do this.

However, we began exchanging into many timeshares in the southeast and the gulf coast of Florida in February and decided we liked the Ft. Lauderdale Beach Resort the best. So we gradually purchased 5 weeks back-to-back (2 bedroom lock-off units) (January to March)and have been using them every year as our "snowbird escape." It saved us the expense and responsibility of buying a full year condo. We can easily rent our timeshares for much more than the maintenance fees if we decide to go somewhere else one year. But that's not feasible now because my mother-in-law is 93 and must come with us when we travel. She is used to our FLBR unit and looks forward to going there every year. We get together with a lot of friends and relatives who either live in Florida full time, or spend several months there in the winter. We have met several people, including some TUGgers, who also own for personal use multiple weeks at our resort. It's VRI managed and they have done a wonderful job renovating it.

Last month while we were in the middle of our 5 week Ft. Lauderdale vacation, a very desirable timeshare in Ft. Myers Beach popped up as a last minute cancellation on the RCI web site. We confirmed it for about $300. out-of-pocket cost and rented our Ft. Lauderdale week while we were away.

We also own 2 beach front weeks near Atlantic City in July and 3 Cape Cod weeks in August. These are drive-to locations for us. We use them often and occasionally rent them.

I still own some weeks purchased in the mid 1990's that we bought as traders. They are nice resorts but we do not care to vacation there, mainly because of the cost and length of the air trip needed to get there. We occasionally trade them through SFX or TPI or Redweek. We are in the process of selling two of them to families who have rented them from us for a few years.

I will be so happy to reach the point where we use everything we own. If we want to go elsewhere in the future, we plan to just rent what we want from an owner. I'll be so glad to be rid of RCI.
 
Last edited:
We use our Wyndham points every year at our home resort (Alexandria). We never get tired of going there ! (We have just enough points for 1 week there per year). We always use our week at Port O Call (Hilton Head) as well.
DH is a golfer, and you can't beat the golf package....The one unit we trade is our week at Spicebush (HH). It trades well since it's in June..we used it the first year we bought it (maybe 5 years ago?) and have traded it every year since. We might actually use it next year as I'm eager to see the upgraded kitchens....:) This year I traded it for a week at the Trapp Family Lodge in Vermont in late May. We've never been to Vermont so are excited about going!
Deb
 
But you did say above that you are in the process of dropping timesharing trips?

http://www.tugbbs.com/forums/showpost.php?p=886831&postcount=38

Yes, you are right but that has nothing to do with being able to exchange. We are dropping them because we far prefer to stay in luxury hotels with room service, all the amenities, and flexibility. If we do want a timeshare, we will just rent a week but that probably won't be very often.
 
I'm truly surprised to see how many people are using their timeshares for exchanges, given the dwindling availability of desirable resorts available through RCI.
Maybe I'm insufficiently discriminating, but I'm able to find weeks that work for me and are fair value (and, often, more than fair) given what I'm putting in.
 
Top