Bill ... I'm surprised you would prefer MBP which is about an hour from you instead of what you have in MMC for a complete change of environment for a holiday.
I think MMC/MSE has one of the best HOA's in the Marriott system and as a long time owner there, feel that if they needed that kind of increase to keep this place very special I'm OK with it because there have been years in which there was little or next to no increase at all. Even with the last 2 years of MF increases it still is very affordable...and there aren't many, if any, Marriotts with MF's that low.
http://www.tug2.net/advice/marriottmf.htm
I think if you bought MMC for trading you're missing out on something very special.
For $845 a year you also get 6 free rounds of golf included .. a significant saving if you pay to play golf anywhere else ... and even if you don't it is
just $121 a night for lovely surroundings. If you wanted to sell, you should easily get 100% back if you bought resale. The suite size is 1350 sq ft and the complex sits in the middle of a very upscale gated residential neighbourhood surrounded by its 54 holes of great golf. Within a 15-30 minute drive you can go to Virginia Beach for the day, Norfolk, Busch Gardens, Water World, Jamestown, historic Williamsburg, etc. etc. For the $1050 MF of BeachPlace, you get nothing extra but an HOA that did
no renos over the last five years and now has to play catch up big time.
Regardless of Redweek's stats, I own at both BeachPlace and Manor Club (also Canyon Villas) and my experience is that Manor Club outstrips MBP in trading power. Just this week I was checking II
with a MSE studio lockoff for availabilities up to the first week of July -- and found
dozens of 2 bedroom suites as well as a 3 bedroom in Spain! Many of those did not show up at all when I searched with my MBP studio. MBP is also harder to rent on Ebay even for President's week than Manor Club - this year I rented the 1 bdrm and the studio of MSE on Ebay for $1490 in a week - 75% more than my cost! My MBP studio for President's week didn't rent at all so I had to turn it in to Interval.
80% of MBP owners either trade for points each year or for other resorts ... probably due to the poor condition of what they own as you can't beat the location if you want beachfront in the winter -- but the cost of the MF to get 110k MR points instead is almost as high as buying them from Marriott.
http://www.tugbbs.com/forums/showpost.php?p=446333&postcount=73
I don't know if you have experienced your ownership of MMC yet, but that might change your opinion. And if MMC's HOA continues with double digit MF increases for 2009 I might change mine too!
Brian
In hindsight, I should have bought there instead of MMC...my MMC annual dues has risen 33% in two years and has lower trading power than Beach place according to redweek.com