For everything there is a season. . . even every sort of investment. I am going to break up the chart that Brett repeats over and over, into periods of investment changes.
1975 to Date
This date was not chosen at random - Jan 01 1975 was the first date that gold could be owned in the US without government approval.
Overall rate was stock +6500% - gold 2300%. Of course for this period to matter you would have to be at least 70 years old and most likely more.
Now we will break this period into sub periods.First 1975 to Feb 1980.
Overall rate for the period. Stocks 20% - gold 250%. Advantage gold for this period.
The next period is Feb 1980 to Jan 2000.
Overall rate is stocks +1150% - gold -64%. Stocks outperformed gold by +3200%.
A unique period, where stock out performed everything, due to the revaluation of financial assets with the ending to the great US inflation.
There's been nothing like it before or since. But it only mattered if you were around and investing at that time - i.e. you have to have been
over 65 for this whole period to apply, and over 50 (as of now) for it to apply at all.
To get a feel for it, the stock-to-GDP ratio went from 40% to 130% over that period, or 3 fold.
The next big period is Jan 2000 to date.
Overall rate is Stocks +320 - Gold +1080%
Gold outperformed stocks 3 fold over this period.
But let's break this period up.
First, Feb 2000 to Feb 2012.
Overall rate Stocks 70% - Gold 475%. Roughly 6X better performance for gold.
Next Feb 2012 to Dec 2019.
Overall rate Stocks +120 - Gold -15% Net advantage to stock by around 150%
Finally Dec 2019 to date.
Overall advantage - Stocks +60% - Gold +160%. Net advantage is to gold - +100%.
Summary. If you look at the stock gain vis-a-vis gold, you find that all that gain was in one period 1980 to 2000, when inflation
cranked down from 18% to 3-4%, inflation which had caused stock to drop in real value (as opposed to nominal value) for the 15 year before 1980.
(This the very period that made Warren Buffet and Charlie Munger look so good for so long.)
Q.E.D.