Hi KTaylor:
I was at an "owner's update" last month, and I discussed the PIC program with the sales rep. I was specifically told that I could not use my existing resale Wyndham points for the PIC. Instead, I would have to buy 154,000 retail points from Wyndham (for approximately $20,000), and then buy a 2 bedroom fixed week resale that qualified for PIC. That would get me VIP status in Wyndham. My next question was whether my existing resale Wyndham points would then be considered VIP like the rest of my new retail Wyndham points. The sales rep replied "probably not."
My sense is that if anyone desperately wants VIP status, PIC is a smart and cheaper way to do it. But I seriously doubt that I ever will take this course for three reasons. One, most (but not all) people seem to agree that VIP benefits aren't worth the extra cost, even when the smart buyer takes advantage of the PIC program. Two, because VIP and PIC can be changed by Wyndham at any time, a buyer is taking a huge risk. And finally, I'm very happy with the cheap resale Wyndham points that I purchased on ebay. Sure, my MF's are probably somewhat higher than a retail purchasers. But since I paid 95% less for my purchase price, I can live with this.