Here is my suggestion - take the WKORV and get your friends with you (what you arrange privately with your friends is something between you and nobody can know what is your agreement). If you really want to try for Harborside or St John I will keep the current exchange and run a search with you next year usage for such trade. If something comes up that you like more you can call II and ask them to use your unit that you already exchanged to WKORV and to release your future use year SBP. This will cost you extra $104 but it is worth it. That is exactly what I did 2 years ago when I switched from confirmed WKORV exchange to HRA.
Keep in mind that St. John is long shot and most of the exchanges you will match will be in the flex-change or close to it. I have no idea about this resort since from all I have heard/read it is not my cup of tea but I have seen it in flex-change.
As for Harbourside - despite your priority you still depend on Starwood depositing such units. I will say chances for the summer HRA are slim to none, for winter you can probably catch something close to the 60-day before check-in and for hurricane season (Late Aug - Oct) chances are fair even outside flex.
As for FSA - you do not have internal priority so you will compete with all other II members and to go there you will have to be flexible and not in prime time. I am booking this resort often for friends on the west coast and it is much easier to do for me with WorldMark but it is hard exchange. I usually leave wide range for such search and check with them after I get match if they can use the week or not.
From
Thank you Denise. It is actually a 2 Bedroomm and only myself and my husband are going since it is our anniversary. Do you know if all of the 2 bedrooms are lock offs? Maybe I could rent the other side to a friend.
My husband wants me to give it up and try for St. John or Atlantis or Avaria. I want to go to Maui. I have 24 hours to decide.
I wont be sorry will I? I think he does not want the 13 hour flight from the east coast. He also really wants to see St John, but I dont think I will get it. This is a September/October request.