Looked for SFO to Milan -- early May next year. Lowest was 200,000 miles
this thread made me ask my wife about exactly what she booked. Turns out she booked only the 1-way to Europe (LUX). 55 K miles + small # of $s. She is waiting on the return, figuring we may spend 3 wks there, and knowing, as I said, there isn't any reason for us to return via LUX. So, pertinent, she is waiting for the return flights to become available, which she says is 10 mos out or slightly more for AA.
Also, she says so far it looks like the best value in AA mile flights coming back from Europe may be Milan & LHR, not LUX. I really don't feel like going to London, so I hope it isn't LHR, but her idea is we could take cheap flight to LHR from a bunch of places in Europe. I guess being there 3 wks makes it easier to schlep around a bit.
So, if you'll be in Milan, you're in the right place but to get a great mileage-price on a return flight, maybe you could delay your trip til next Aug/Sept, and hit that 10 mo availability?
there is a site called pointsyeah.com that might help greatly. She doesn't use it. She's just a power-user of AA & UAL FF sites.