I think it is okay for prime summer weeks but late Fall, Winter and very early Spring in my opinion is a ripoff. Let the owners drop enough of them and see what happens....bankruptcy !!!!
How many resorts with fixed weeks have different maintenance fees for the different seasons?
Yes, it's a problem that wasn't foreseen most likely when the timeshare docs were set up. This isn't an issue only at Peppertree Atlantic Beach or with Festiva and Peppertree's BOD. Perhaps this is the only resort that you are familiar with, but this is not unique to PAB.
Most of these legacy resorts are doomed to failure in the future as off-season (and some prime season) owners start walking in greater numbers with each passing year. Knowing this potential, will you continue trying to prop up the resort as a Summer weeks owner with your maintenance fees. Older resorts take a ton of money to keep maintained.
The Tugger that I had a conversation with today, that owns at a resort where I have been an owner since 1984, knows all to well, as I do, about a deteriorating resort with no end in sight. The only recourse has been to bill special assessments to put a band-aid on things, afraid of raising maintenance fees to a level that ensures reserves. But in the end, it's not increased maintenance fees per se that makes folks walk away from this never-ending obligation. It's more the whole package; maintenance fees in general, deteriorating properties, delinquencies, changes to lifestyle and travel preferences, and a whole myriad of other things. The fact that there have been no solutions to negate these things and come up with exit strategies is why resorts may be headed for bankruptcy.
IMHO your blame is very misplaced. I'm curious, with your past and present posts, why you keep buying into this resort. Sure, you're buying Summer weeks, but in the end bankruptcy is bankruptcy.