Carolinian
TUG Member
Actually, you sometimes have the resources to check the whole market, and eBay sales are a tiny fraction of that for most areas.
On the Outer Banks, the local Land Transfer Tax office requires a sworn affidavit as to actual price paid, and they post those sale prices online. I have several times done analysis of the quantity of actual sales and average actual sale prices for several categories of weeks, and compared the current market volume with similar periods before the 2008 economic downturn. It is an eye opener to look at broad real data, and it makes you realize how inconsequential eBay is. I have several times posted those results on these boards.
This does not work many places in North Carolina, because the state tax stamps placed on deeds in most counties do not require sworn affidavits, and thus they will put any amount you want on them. I would have much less confidence in the accuracy of numbers under those procedures.
On the Outer Banks, the local Land Transfer Tax office requires a sworn affidavit as to actual price paid, and they post those sale prices online. I have several times done analysis of the quantity of actual sales and average actual sale prices for several categories of weeks, and compared the current market volume with similar periods before the 2008 economic downturn. It is an eye opener to look at broad real data, and it makes you realize how inconsequential eBay is. I have several times posted those results on these boards.
This does not work many places in North Carolina, because the state tax stamps placed on deeds in most counties do not require sworn affidavits, and thus they will put any amount you want on them. I would have much less confidence in the accuracy of numbers under those procedures.
I tend to agree with swaits although one thing that is becoming apparent to me is that timeshare weeks do not have a well-defined value that is the same to all participants.
What I think is clear is that if weeks sell for a nominal sum on, say, eBay then it's really not plausible that they are "worth" a great deal more. There is going to be a range though - in such a fragmented market where it is hard to get comfortable with the market participants.
If it were possible to actually see the full range of prices achieved, that would be a very interesting set of data. I suppose the timeshare companies do have that information because all the trades have to be disclosed to them but they obviously would never make that public - it would be quite damaging to their primary sales business.