So sorry your pickles did not work out the way you wanted; I know that was a disappointment. We have used the Claussen pickles from the store for many years now, but occasionally I think about my good old pickle making days and wish I had a garden again.
My mother made very good dill pickles, not the fermented kind. She grew her own dill, so put a sprig of dill in each jar, a very tiny hot red pepper and one cherry leaf off of the cherry tree in her front yard. That cherry leaf gave it the best flavor, very subtle. But if she made pickles without it, we could tell right away.