Cathy, we stayed at Paniolo Greens for 2 wks. last Oct., and we much prefer the resorts in Kona. I do agree, the rooms are large and the resort is close to some great beaches, but - Kona is warmer and Paniolo Greens gets very windy. Even after dinner, when I like to go for my walk, it still is so windy. Plus, as others have said, not much in restaurants close by.
So, if you want to cook your own meals, like it windy, try out Paniolo for 1 wk. and see what you think.