I would still pay the difference to own Oceanfront considering that GO is one of the resorts that uses a rotational system for unit placements, which means that even during the highest-demand periods as an owner you're likely to be placed in the "best" of oceanfront at least as often as you're placed in the "worst" (and everything in-between.) Plus the differential is only paid once, at purchase, so it'd be worth it to me. And finally, the "worst" of oceanside units at GO all the way at the back of the resort furthest from the ocean don't appeal to me AT ALL - it feels very crowded and dark back there.
But then again, I'd choose to own an oceanfront Barony or oceanvista SurfWatch over Grande Ocean, hands down.
Different strokes. We own 4 GO weeks which we occupy and never trade, we own 2 Barony weeks which we always trade, and I didn't (and wouldn't) purchase at Surfwatch (although we use bonus weeks there all the time).
I pored and pondered over SW long before construction, during construction, and after construction, but could never get that feel we were after. I was excited initially, and was very ready to buy another......but couldn't pull the trigger.
GO is the consensus #1 Marriott resort at Hilton Head, so I'm not THAT biased.
At GO, the farthest buildings from the ocean are the same distance as the closest SINGLE building at Surfwatch (and all other SW buildings are pretty far), and that's important to us as a family.
The Googlemap's aerial views clearly show this, as I've posted links several times. That said, SW is a great resort. The villas are among the best. Not superior because they're slightly smaller than GO's, but still equally superb in quality. The SW pools are rather small, however, and there are only 2. The settings and feels at these two resorts are very different, but both fantastic. GO has 3 very large pools and an additional small but decent sized lap pool, and numerous outdoor hot tubs---all important to our family. Also a large fire pit area and another small one. No comparison in these regards.
http://goo.gl/maps/y4xvm
And....Barony is far too congested. We stayed there oceanfront last summer on a trade in July and frankly we couldn't wait to get out of there. Too many bodies, too little outdoor space. Just me, I guess. Again, beautiful villas, though, but also smaller than GO's villas, but larger than SW's. Each subsequent construction had smaller villas by a few square feet, but it's very noticeable to us, especially when we include extra family or friends.
Barony used the European Spa when marketing pre-construction (we bit on that one, and never used it), SW used the 3-BR. I guess that's how you justify smaller units. That was my personal conclusion.
Having said all that, I totally respect those who love Barony and Surfwatch----both are head and shoulders above other HH resorts (Harbour Club is very high on my list too, though, and I feel it's vastly underrated. We stay there when we can. Quite a view of waterway.) Each has its own attractive features, and I do adore the SW setting in that gorgeous marshland area----it's totally beautiful, and frankly more serene and spacious a resort than all the others.
.