• The TUGBBS forums are completely free and open to the public and exist as the absolute best place for owners to get help and advice about their timeshares for more than 30 years!

    Join Tens of Thousands of other Owners just like you here to get any and all Timeshare questions answered 24 hours a day!
  • TUG started 31 years ago in October 1993 as a group of regular Timeshare owners just like you!

    Read about our 31st anniversary: Happy 31st Birthday TUG!
  • TUG has a YouTube Channel to produce weekly short informative videos on popular Timeshare topics!

    Free memberships for every 50 subscribers!

    Visit TUG on Youtube!
  • TUG has now saved timeshare owners more than $24,000,000 dollars just by finding us in time to rescind a new Timeshare purchase! A truly incredible milestone!

    Read more here: TUG saves owners more than $24 Million dollars
  • Sign up to get the TUG Newsletter for free!

    Tens of thousands of subscribing owners! A weekly recap of the best Timeshare resort reviews and the most popular topics discussed by owners!
  • Our official "end my sales presentation early" T-shirts are available again! Also come with the option for a free membership extension with purchase to offset the cost!

    All T-shirt options here!
  • A few of the most common links here on the forums for newbies and guests!

VacationShare Worked As Described, Funds Received

NextVacay

Guest
Joined
May 26, 2025
Messages
5
Reaction score
5
Resorts Owned
Wyndham
Having just been paid by VacationShare, I decided to share my experience as a way to repay all the help TUG has given me. First let me share several “tips:”
  • Book a unit within the 60 days of the starting date to minimize your point usage/discount.
  • Submit the booking that you cannot use on the VacationShare account ASAP to maximize the amount of time it is listed on the market.
  • Submit only what VacationShare will take. When you first log in to your VacationShare account, to the lefthand side is a clickable link called “Black Out Dates.” It is supposed to be a list of resorts that participate in the program and their blackout dates. But it is not the final version. You can access the final (or current working) list of resorts when you start to submit your listing. In that form, the dropdown list of participating resorts is shorter than the list on the Black Out Dates. Also, once you have submitted your listing, you wait for it to be approved. VacationShare has the final say.
  • Be patient. The process, if you follow tip 1, takes 60 days + length of booking + 6 weeks. Do this only if you don’t need constant updates because the VacationShare account is quite bare. When I finally got someone on the phone and I told her I waited 45 minutes, her response was, “Oh, that’s short. It was over 2 hours before.”
Here is the long version of what I did. Two months before Spring Break, I booked the weekends before or after Spring Break at popular locations. (VacationShare will not allow a user to submit two listings at the same resort, the same weekend, or overlapping days.) When I cannot use them myself, I submitted my three bookings on my VacationShare account, choosing the MaxShare (60/40 split) model, which means the listing will have exposure to more than Extra Holidays (which has a bad reputation as you all know). Submitting the booking means you have signed legally binding contract digitally, providing your social security number and all. They approved them within 48 hours which means they start to promote them on their platforms. Then I waited. Six weeks after the first booking was completed, I received three emails giving me further instructions on how to receive the funds. To receive the funds, I had to provide my social security number and bank account information and to sign a legal document digitally. Funds were transferred to my bank account almost immediately upon completion of the digital equivalent of paper work.

VacationShare can deny your booking. They send out approval and denial emails within 2 days of submission and update them within your account. I had two submissions denied. Once it is denied, you can cancel the booking in Wyndham and get back the points if it is still within the window when you can do that.

During the waiting time, I tried to call VacationShare three times and to e-mail three times to ask questions. None of the e-mails were responded to. I only got through one time by phone. The person on the phone needed to put me on hold in order to tell me if any of my bookings were rented out (i.e., the information was not on the same system). At that point, two out of the three bookings were partially rented out.

I ask the VacationShare rep on the phone if I can cancel a listing on my end. She said yes, but the answer is you can request to cancel but VacationShare can deny your request. In your VacationShare account, you can click on a listing. On the upper righthand side is a red button for “Request to Cancel.” Use that to make your request. I did not do this so I can’t say anymore.

The VacationShare account is really only there for you to submit your booking and to keep track of whether it has been approved. It does not tell you when a listing has been rented out partially, in full or not at all. It does not indicate if you have been paid.

Even upon payment, I cannot tell which payment was for which listing. The emails telling me to get the money had nothing that indicate which contract was being fulfilled. Since I got three emails, I assumed all three of my listing were rented out at least partially. But that is just my assumption. Without that level of detail, I cannot analyze further without making more assumptions.

Is it worth it? I won’t know until I get the tax documents next year and file taxes on the earnings. One way to limit your tax liability is to restrict your listings to one state. But that may not be feasible for everyone.

All the best to everyone!
 
Is this "Extra Holidays" or is it something different?
 
Is this "Extra Holidays" or is it something different?
Different.
 
Is this "Extra Holidays" or is it something different?
It’s a replacement for Extra Holidays, now with an online platform for the owner but generally similar terms as before. “Extra Holidays” continues to exist as a public-facing website for cash stays, but there is no Extra Holidays rental program for owners anymore. Vacationshare is the only game in town, and feeds rental listings to the public Extra Holidays website as EH did before.
 
Is this how the various Wyndham rental stuff on eBay work, or are those rentals violating the terms and so wouldn't be safe to use?
 
Thank you for the detailed description of the process. It is very helpful. I am curious, regardless of the tax implications, how much did you earn per 1K points? I know you have no idea what rented and what did not, but you were out a certain number of points and received a certain amount of money. That would be a very interesting data point, even if just one among many. I expect what they charge on EH has a lot to do with time and location so nothing is guaranteed. Anyway... Just curious.
 
It’s a replacement for Extra Holidays, now with an online platform for the owner but generally similar terms as before. “Extra Holidays” continues to exist as a public-facing website for cash stays, but there is no Extra Holidays rental program for owners anymore. Vacationshare is the only game in town, and feeds rental listings to the public Extra Holidays website as EH did before.
:(:censored:
 
Thank you for the detailed description of the process. It is very helpful. I am curious, regardless of the tax implications, how much did you earn per 1K points? I know you have no idea what rented and what did not, but you were out a certain number of points and received a certain amount of money. That would be a very interesting data point, even if just one among many. I expect what they charge on EH has a lot to do with time and location so nothing is guaranteed. Anyway... Just curious.

I'm going to go out on a limb and guess that most people did not pay ANY taxes on their timeshare rental schemes when they were able to do them on their own. The third party companies have to send you tax documents, which alerts the government to your rental business, so you are kind of forced to pay your taxes. This is not a bad thing.
 
Can you provide a general synopsis.

Who sets the price?
Can they rent out only a portion of the days you make available. If so this is the issue I had with EH.
What accountability and tracking did they provide. Again, EH has NO visibility and you had to take their word on everything
60/40 is the split? Wow that is a big chunk. What other options are there and what do you get for those options?
 
Last edited:
Is this how the various Wyndham rental stuff on eBay work, or are those rentals violating the terms and so wouldn't be safe to use?
VacationShare is safe to use based on my experience. VacationShare is promoted during sales. Wyndham's parent company makes this method available to owners to monetize their extra points or bookings they cannot use due to change of plans.
 
Is this "Extra Holidays" or is it something different?
I would explain it as Extra Holiday is now a subset of VacationShare. When you select how you want your deposit to be promoted, you can choose Extra Holidays, which means your deposit will only be marketed on Extra Holidays, and, if it is rented out, you will receive 70% of the money.

My understanding is that Vacationshare is more than Extra Holidays in that you can choose the Max Share option, which means your deposit will be marketed on a wider variety of platforms that the parent company now owns, and, if it is rented out, you will receive 60% of the money.
 
Can you provide a general synopsis.

Who sets the price?
Can they rent out only a portion of the days you make available. If so this is the issue I had with EH.
What accountability and tracking did they provide. Again, EH has NO visibility and you had to take their word on everything
60/40 is the split? Wow that is a big chunk. What other options are there and what do you get for those options?
My guess is that the parent company sets the price. When you submit your deposit, you will be shown a high and low price for each day of your deposit and a disclaimer that they cannot guarantee you will get that much or that all the days will be rented.

For sure they can rent out a portion of the days you make available. In the one phone call I was able to get through, the representative clearly told me that two of my deposits was partially rented out at that moment. But someone else could come along later and rent what was left.

In your VacationShare account, you can submit a deposit, see whether it is approved or denied and request a cancellation. You cannot see in your VacationShare account which day of your deposit is rented out. I called and talked with a representative who was able to tell me that. But it took so long to get through I would just take their word for it. Even if VacationShare had a tracking function, are we not also taking their word for it? In this day and age, I do believe they can make VacationShare better, with more functionality.

The other option is Extra Holidays only and you get back 70%.
 
Last edited:
My guess is that the parent company sets the price. When you submit your deposit, you will be shown a high and low price for each day of your deposit and a disclaimer that they cannot guarantee you will get that much or that all the days will be rented.

For sure they can rent out a portion of the days you make available. In the one phone call I was able to get through, the representative clearly told me that one of my deposits was partially rented out at that moment. But someone else could come along later and rent what was left.

In your VacationShare account, you can submit a deposit, see whether it is approved or denied and request a cancellation. You cannot see in your VacationShare account which day of your deposit is rented out. I called and talked with a representative who was able to tell me things. But it took so long to get through I would just take their word for it. Even if VacationShare had a tracking function, are we not also taking their word for it? In this day and age, I do believe they can make VacationShare better, with more functionality.

The other option is Extra Holidays only and you get back 70%.
:LOL::ROFLMAO:
 
Thank you for the detailed description of the process. It is very helpful. I am curious, regardless of the tax implications, how much did you earn per 1K points? I know you have no idea what rented and what did not, but you were out a certain number of points and received a certain amount of money. That would be a very interesting data point, even if just one among many. I expect what they charge on EH has a lot to do with time and location so nothing is guaranteed. Anyway... Just curious.
I got back more than $7 per 1K points spent
The amount of point spent is low because I booked within 60 days and my status allows for 50% off points.
If you booked a vacation a year in advance using the full amount of points, your calculus would be different. If life throws you a lemon and you can't go on that vacation any more, VacationShare is there for you to get something back. The sales people emphasize that this program is not for people to build a vacation rental business on.
 
Last edited:
I got back more than $7 per 1K points spent
The amount of point spent is low because I booked within 60 days and my status allows for 50% off points.
If you booked a vacation a year in advance using the full amount of points, your calculus would be different. If life throws you a lemon and you can't go on that vacation any more, VacationShare is there for you to get something back. The sales people emphasize that this program is not for people to build a vacation rental business on.
Thank you for creating this thread! It answered some of the questions my wife and I had with VacationShare. They hooked us on this for us to consolidate two contracts (one deeded at Glacier Canyon and another was Access). We'd had some positive experience with Extra Holidays, so were hoping for more of the same.

But ya, our sales rep said we could pay off half our loan in one year with VacationShare, which is laughable.

Glad to hear that the remaining days not picked up are not lost, but can still be rented out.

Agree with you that VS seems very lacking and should have more information available in regards to rental status. Seems like an easy handshake with their other system handling the sales of rentals.

Wish us luck as we rake in the $MILLIONS$ through VS! :ROFLMAO:
 
I'm going to go out on a limb and guess that most people did not pay ANY taxes on their timeshare rental schemes when they were able to do them on their own. The third party companies have to send you tax documents, which alerts the government to your rental business, so you are kind of forced to pay your taxes. This is not a bad thing.
I did through a corp. No way to avoid that.
 
I'm going to go out on a limb and guess that most people did not pay ANY taxes on their timeshare rental schemes when they were able to do them on their own. The third party companies have to send you tax documents, which alerts the government to your rental business, so you are kind of forced to pay your taxes. This is not a bad thing.

I think your view is unjustifiably dark.

Edit: This might be a good topic for a poll.
 
Can you provide a general synopsis.

Who sets the price?
The vendor does (i.e. not the owner). I would prefer that the owner could set a floor price when submitting their reservation for rental, as in a $/1000 floor price basically.
Can they rent out only a portion of the days you make available. If so this is the issue I had with EH.
Same issue still exists. I would prefer that there be an option via a checkbox to allow the owner to choose whether to only rent the entire reservation, or if a partial rental is acceptable. Give the owner a bit more input input and control over the terms of renting their reservation basically. Sure it may make renting your reservation less likely, but that's a choice for the owner to make IMHO.
What accountability and tracking did they provide. Again, EH has NO visibility and you had to take their word on everything
60/40 is the split? Wow that is a big chunk. What other options are there and what do you get for those options?
It's 70/30 using EH only, or 6/40 to branch outside of EH.

Basically it seems like VS is simply separating out the capture of inventory to rent from the EH website. The EH website is now only for advertising inventory for consumers to rent from Wyndham, whether Wyndham-owned or owner-owned inventory.
 
I'm going to go out on a limb and guess that most people did not pay ANY taxes on their timeshare rental schemes when they were able to do them on their own. The third party companies have to send you tax documents, which alerts the government to your rental business, so you are kind of forced to pay your taxes. This is not a bad thing.
That is such a bold statement, very accusatory, when in actuality, most people do pay their taxes on income earned because getting caught has terrible ramifications. All money is tracked by banks and institutions. How do you cash any check or accept any payment without going through a bank.

This is such a ridiculous post.
 
That is such a bold statement, very accusatory, when in actuality, most people do pay their taxes on income earned because getting caught has terrible ramifications. All money is tracked by banks and institutions. How do you cash any check or accept any payment without going through a bank.

This is such a ridiculous post.

Glad I'm not the only one with this opinion.
 
Glad I'm not the only one with this opinion.

And you know what they say about opinons, right?

Anyway, tax evasion issue aside, i'm just glad the megarenters got shut down. More availability for the rest of us.
 
And you know what they say about opinons, right?

Anyway, tax evasion issue aside, i'm just glad the megarenters got shut down. More availability for the rest of us.

Speaking of being shut down, you were shut down from the Wyndham forum a while back, no?
 
Speaking of being shut down, you were shut down from the Wyndham forum a while back, no?

Awwwww, poor baby's feelings hurt?

Nobody cares that you all lost your illicit income stream. The rest of us got our ownership back.

No regerts as some have said.
 
Last edited:
So, weren't you kicked off the forum?
 
The only real difference between Vaction Share and Extra Holidays is that with VS the owner does more of the work in getting their stay listed. Which means Wyndham does less for their cut. The advantage to the owners is that their stay actually does get listed, and in a timely manner too, so there is that small bit of control they didn’t have with EH.

EH/VS could be an absolutely stellar program. Unfortunately in many vital aspects in regards to how it's set up and run, it's sadly lacking. In his post HitchHker71 listed some of those areas that need improved or changed.

I have to wonder if the PTB (powers that be) in Wyndham even have a clue about the program's insufficienties and more importantly to them, the as of now unfulfilled potential to make them much, much more money.
 
Top