We had a situation here where my son 16 was dating my 17 yo daughters best friend. They are all within 10 months of each other age wise, but my son missed being in the same grade as my daughter by 2 weeks.
Anyway, they dated for about 18 months and then about 2 weeks after the semi back in Nov, my son broke up with her. He later told me that he loved her, but was not IN love with her. Before he even got home, while we were still unaware that this had happened, her mother was on the phone screaming at me that the whole thing happened because I took my children away for most of August and he was changed when he came back, how could he do this, blah, blah, blah. We all liked the girl alot but I had always kept saying "its too soon". I finally just told the mother that if they are meant to be together they will eventually get together. My son was also devastated. When he came home I could tell how upset he was and when we finally talked about it, he asked me what should he have done, stayed with her even though the feelings weren't there anymore?
Well, over the next few days, all the girl could post on her facebook was "oh, my fairytale is over", "What am I going to do...", " my dreams are crushed". I was seriously worried about the girl.
I don't want to sound judgemental here, so I hope I don't offend anyone. The weirdest thing about the whole thing was that the girl's mother had gotten pregnant at a very young age, she never went to college, she was a single mom and because of this they always talked about the very high hopes they have for this girl who is a very smart girl. I am not saying there is anything wrong with the mother, just that considering how she always said she didn't want the same thing for her daughter, I couldn't understand why she wanted her to be serious with a boy in the first place.
I asked my son back then to please try not to get serious with anyone until much much later. He enjoys having lots of girl friends, just not girlfriends. And if you can't enjoy having lots of girl friends when you are 16/17, when can you do it?