I was in communication with a few other tuggers until late this past July about trading into the Carolinas. I was looking to trade into OceanWatch and so was someone else and a few others were trying to get into Hilton Head. Basically, those of us who could take a late August week were succesfull but it took until just about flex time to happen. The DC really messed things up for the Carolinas this past summer. Maybe summer of 2012 will be a little different.
I wouldn't take my comments as gospel, that's for sure but I did/do follow the Carolina exchanges best I can. I think I remember one tugger who owned a platinum Aruba week or something very high value who was able to get into OceanWatch for earlier in the summer than late August, and that was after nearly a year of waiting. Other than that, the only success stories I have heard have been the same kind of week you got, the very end of Summer, and probably start of school season for most kids.
I just would hate for you to spend close to 10k, when in reality (more times than not) you will be able to get that week with what you already have. Maybe you can try for that last week of August one more time and then see where resale prices are and maybe even by then, tuggers will start reporting successful exchanges into the Carolinas for earlier in the summer.
For now, if you want early August of July or mid June, you most likely need to own there or own a very exotic week (like presidents day ski week at a Marriott or New Years in Hawaii) to get a summer Carolina week at the big three Hilton Head Marriotts and you can all but forget about OceanWatch, no matter what you own.
I hope I am wrong about that -- would love to hear from some tuggers who own an inland Marriott week that were able to trade into the Carolinas for a peak July week. Just haven't heard from anyone, yet.
Really? Hmm... If I could get it everyweek, I'd be happy, but it seems like it's risky. My wife has said for the year after next, we cannot do it as we'll miss an orientation/open house for my son as he begins kindergarten, but that's not an issue until summer 2013.