George:
Yeah, everything is relative. We've found that we greatly enjoy St John and consider it the best place on earth. We want to return every year at the same time and want the 3 bedrooms for the private pool and the room to bring other family and friends. Plus with Starwood, we have the assurance that we will be able to trade, either directly or with Staroptions, for other quality resorts.
Ok, maybe our standards are high, but after a horrible time last year at Marriott Grande Vista, we won't stay anywhere but a Starwood Timeshare. MGV actually gave us a brand new two bedroom unit, but it was a ground floor unit and the people above us kept very different hours and we didn't get much sleep because of their walking back and forth heavily and wearing heavy shoes/heels on the bathroom tiles. We were also put off by the whole "mega" resort; it took about 10 minutes just to drive to our unit from the road. The amenities were nice, but certainly not better than our WSJ.
The wonderful thing about timesharing is that you can find what you want in a location you love if you just spend the time/money on it. Some people really enjoy "bargain" hunting, but that rarely if ever has been an option at St John. Truly, if you want to go there every year, and want a 3 bedroom, you have to buy there. Sure, our investment was high, but we've been fortunate enough to be able to do this. We rarely take vacations anywhere but St John, but that's our choice, not an economic necessity.
Some people who visit St John rent villas, not timeshares, every year and that's great if it works for them. With our child, we like the Kid's Club availability, and we also appreciate the on-site car rental and the Westin Ferry service. Others don't. Again, too each his own.
Lori