IMO, Hyatt and Marriott were the 2 best alternatives in terms of hotel loyalty programs. Although I like Hilton hotels, and especially like their presence in Hawaii, their redemption rates are too high for non-business travelers.
I judge this based on how many points it would take ME (100% leisure traveler) to earn a free night. Since we're empty nesters now, our biggest spending is restaurant and home improvement stores. Since the only way I earn points is via credit card spending, it's key that my hotel-branded credit card earns a nice redemption for those categories.
Here's a quick Hyatt v Marriott comparison:
Hyatt Gold Passport
Credit card spending Points Earned:
- 3 points per $1 spent at all Hyatt properties*
- 2 points per $1 spent at restaurants, on airline tickets
- purchased directly from the airline, and at car rental agencies*
- 1 point per $1 spent on all other purchases made with your card
Plus, 1 free night every year after your cardmember anniversary at any Category 1-4 property
Redemption rates for Hyatt hotels:
Category # of points per night
Standard Room:
1 5,000
2 8,000
3 12,000
4 15,000
5 20,000
6 25,000
7 30,000
Regency/Grand Club:
1 7,000
2 12,000
3 17,000
4 21,000
5 27,000
6 33,000
7 39,000
HGCV properties:
Studio: 12,000
One Bedroom: 15,000
Two Bedroom: 23,000
Three Bedroom: 30,000
So immediately I notice that Category 7 rooms are quite expensive, but middle of the room rates are doable. And the HGCV properties aren't bad, either, comparatively speaking. Unlike Starwood or Marriott, there's no break for 5+ nights.
Compare this to Marriott:
Marriott Rewards Program
Credit card earning:
Earn unlimited Marriott Rewards® points and get free stays faster
- 5 points for every $1 spent at over 4,000 Marriott® locations, including our exclusive luxury hotel partner, The Ritz-Carlton®*
- 2 points for every $1 spent on airline tickets purchased directly with the airline, and at car rental agencies and restaurants*
- 1 point for every $1 spent on purchases anywhere else*
Plus 1 free night stay at a Category 1-5 hotel every year after your account anniversary*
Category MRs @ regular redemption
MRs @ Saver Rates
1 7,500
6,000
2 10,000
7,500
3 15,000
10,000
4 20,000
15,000
5 25,000
20,000
6 30,000
25,000
7 35,000
30,000
8 40,000
35,000
9 45,000
40,000
Redeem 4 Nights. Get the 5th Night FREE!
This was a great perk, but alas, Hyatt does not offer it.