For myself, I like Crestview the best. They are the newer of the group.
Crestview is at Wyndham Shawnee Resort.
Shawnee is very pretty at this time of the year. Sort of sits between the Delaware River (Shawnee is riverfront) and the ridge across the street from Shawnee is why the Delaware River has that curve in it.
Why stay at Shawnee? It has a LARGE BIG indoor pool. A full size gym, too. Plus a strong activities program ... DO NOT MISS the Monday night Karokee ... free (wine and other less hard) beverages AND excellent singers (about 1/2 are resort employees either on their 2nd shift lunch break OR off duty) ... seems most came to the area hoping from the Great White Way (Broadway) or then, the less Shawnee Playhouse or cheap area to live but still able to drive into THE CITY.
The other Villages (called such as they are different styles and ages of this large resort) were built from 1974 and on. Almost every unit is a 2/2 (some 1bdr in the Fairways Village). Most with either wood or gas fireplaces. Most with porches and some are screen-in. Most are 2 story units (except Crestview).
Lots of things to do and see ... I really liked taking
the coal mine tour several years ago ... perfect for ANY type of weather (but don't know if it is still around). If not, the outlet mall shopping near Camelback Ski mountain will distract the women ... but if still open, so would the drive to the TOP of the mountain past the Camelback Ski Entrance (Park with a loop) ...if still with leaves, pretty. If not leaves, still great. Don't know if the fire tower is still open ... wear warm clothes .. pretty COLD wind blows up there.
But have fun ... might be more nature than you like ... black bears, deer and foxes are regular SEEN at Shawnee .. in the parking lots, trash bins, along the roads ... the bears are NOT TAME - avoid at all costs.
Enjoy!