Helios
TUG Member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2015
- Messages
- 2,297
- Reaction score
- 134
Yes, it's mandatory. 81,000 points a year. And I'm trying to sell it.
I never should have bought it. With nothing against the Starwood resorts, the program just doesn't have the flexibility that Hilton does. I see SVO much more as a basic timeshare program where you get a week a year. Sure, you can trade with II into some pretty sweet properties, but you're going to trade your week for a different week. With HGVC you can play your cards right and take the points from your 2BR platinum week and book 3 or 4 weeks in lower seasons and smaller units. Or break it into a bunch of 3-day weekends if you want.
I also like that HGVC lets you borrow points from the next year without having to pay the next years fees. I tried that (booking my 2016 week before I paid my 2016 dues (due 1/1/16) and they wouldn't allow it.
Hilton has a ton of options/resorts, many ways to slice and dice your points, and is really a one-stop shop (unless you venture out into RCI). I found that with SVO and dealing with II it just seems more complicated and more restricted. For example, when I booked my first II trade/week I had to pay an extra fee ($39?) if I wanted to be able to change the reservation at some point in the future. And we're talking about a trip that was 9 or 10 months away. With Hilton you can book whatever you want and as long as you cancel more than 30 days out you get your points back (you lose your $49 fee if you cancel, you don't lose your fee if you just change your dates and/or resort rather than cancel the trip completely).
I'm trying to sell SVO so I can use that money to buy more HGVC points. I really haven't given SVO a shot but have decided that the "fun" of trying a new system isn't worth it and I want all my eggs (and points) in one bucket.
I actually like Starwood a lot and have a good understanding of how you can maximize your ownership and achieve many of the shortcomings you mentioned. I think a problem you may have is that you could use more staroptions. But, depending on where you go, when, and on what unit size, you could conceivably be able to reserve multiple weekends.
I know II is expensive and has many fees. I don't know RCI so I can't comment on that.
HGVC has many resorts and seems to be on expansion mode which I find very appealing. I don't know how to compare overall resort quality. Starwood's elite program seem to offer better benefits.
I think the bad news for you are that Starwood FL resorts, including mandatory phases but to a lesser extent, don't hold their value and sometimes need to be given away.