• Welcome to the FREE TUGBBS forums! The absolute best place for owners to get help and advice about their timeshares for more than 32 years!

    Join Tens of Thousands of other owners just like you here to get any and all Timeshare questions answered 24 hours a day!
  • TUG started 33 years ago in October 1993 as a group of regular Timeshare owners just like you!

    Read about our 33nd anniversary and giveaway: Happy 32nd Birthday TUG!
  • TUG has a YouTube Channel to produce weekly short informative videos on popular Timeshare topics!

    All subscribers auto-entered to win all free TUG membership giveaways!

    Visit TUG on Youtube!
  • TUG has now saved timeshare owners more than $25,000,000 dollars just by finding us in time to rescind a new Timeshare purchase! A truly incredible milestone!

    Read more here: TUG saves owners more than $25 Million dollars
  • Sign up to get the TUG Newsletter for free!

    Tens of thousands of subscribing owners! A weekly recap of the best Timeshare resort reviews and the most popular topics discussed by owners!
  • Our official "end my sales presentation early" T-shirts are available again! Also come with the option for a free membership extension with purchase to offset the cost!

    All T-shirt options here!
  • A few of the most common links here on the forums for newbies and guests!

Reasons why Hawaii is becoming an unpopular destination for tourists

easyrider

TUG Review Crew: Elite
TUG Member
Joined
Aug 21, 2005
Messages
20,050
Reaction score
12,647
Location
Palm Springs of Washinton
Resorts Owned
Worldmark * * Villa Del Palmar UVCI * * Vacation Internationale*
Hawaii is certainly a destination for us. About the only thing I don't like is the long flights and airport time. We have been isolated a bit from the costs and locals because we use timeshares for stays, points for flights and I look like a local. Hawaii has lost tourists and the resorts are not being kept up partly because of shoreline rules and other regulations.

The article is kind of off with hyperbolic car rental quotes but spot on about parking and traffic. I'm reluctant to go to Kauai because of traffic. Maui isn't the same without Lahaina, imo. Hawaii and Oahu are about it for liking the area for us.

Bill

 
Common man. Traffic in Kauai is driving you away? Seriously? You've never driven in the Puget Sound?
 
The standard Hawaii vacation is over
The year started strong for tourism, but that changed when the two kona lows brought widespread flooding in March. More severe weather followed in April, Hurricane Lala and Tropical Storm Moke arrived in August and Hurricane Lowell hit in September.

As a series of storms, powered by a strong El Niño, continued to skirt around the Islands, the number of visitors on any given day dropped dramatically. In March, the average daily visitor census was down 5.1% compared with the year before. The decline widened to 11.2% in June and 13.1% in July.

But fewer people weren’t necessarily coming to Hawaii — more visitors arrived in July than the year before. The difference is that they’re not staying as long. In July alone, visitors spent about 1 million fewer days in Hawaii than they did in July 2025.
 
That reads like AI written ... information. That said, it makes sense - economics will manage scarcity eventually. I'm really on the fence about Hawaii, but I've been leaning "no" for a while after what I've been exposed to on this site. I am currently marveling at how great the beaches in Miramar Beach FL are on the Gulf in late September. So far, still no impossible parking. I really can't imagine a better beach.

If I wanted an Island, I feel like the Caribbean is closer and maybe cheaper. If I wanted to fly a very long flight, I still really really want to go to Japan, and maybe New Zealand and Australia over what I gather from that article is in Hawaii. And it's not just that article.

I will quibble with the all inclusive ad in the middle for Mexico, while I guess the price is known, it's also way more expensive than MOST PEOPLE could actually "break even" on. It's not a cheap option the way the article implies, at least not to me. I actually so far will only go to places that aren't "All Inclusive" because it costs so much. I've seen prices regularly of $1,500 per person, and I do not believe we spend that much per person to eat in a week. You would have to go to what are pretty expensive restaurants 2x a day to blow past that, and all 7 days, which we really don't manage to schedule on arrival and departure days.

I will say, to the extent I can get a non all-inclusive, I am considering Mexico more than Hawaii, simply because of being closer.

I also think the other thing is I saw an article saying people are more gravitating to cruises, and while I've been scared of the "petri dish" of cruises, I think I'd try them first if I was going to pay all inclusive fees.
 
Common man. Traffic in Kauai is driving you away? Seriously? You've never driven in the Puget Sound?

It took us over an hour to get from Kapa'a to Poipu to go diving. Sea Sport told us to leave 90 minutes early and we did. In the winter, the south side of Kauai is often the only diving going on. We should have stayed in Poipu is what we decided.

Bill
 
I will say, to the extent I can get a non all-inclusive, I am considering Mexico more than Hawaii, simply because of being closer.

That is what we do. I do like flying to the closer Mexico better than Hawaii other than occasionally getting stuck at the Mexican Immigration and Customs. We have Global Entry so coming home is ok. Non-all-inclusive does limit where we can go. One thing for sure is the resorts in Mexico that we like are more opulent with nicer beaches than anywhere we have stayed in Hawaii. Even so, we do love some places Hawaii.

Bill
 
That is what we do. I do like flying to the closer Mexico better than Hawaii other than occasionally getting stuck at the Mexican Immigration and Customs. We have Global Entry so coming home is ok. Non-all-inclusive does limit where we can go. One thing for sure is the resorts in Mexico that we like are more opulent with nicer beaches than anywhere we have stayed in Hawaii. Even so, we do love some places Hawaii.

Bill
I also kind of prefer Mexico’s resorts. Daily maid service, twice per day typically, and they are lovely. The food is also better in Mexico, imo. We did return from Maui recently, and were lucky to dodge all the storms. I knew the beach was eroded quite a bit but it was still a shock to see. That said, we loved our trip - just a different vibe. We are hoping to go back in a few years and also visit Oahu sometime.
 
I'm reluctant to go to Kauai because of traffic. Maui isn't the same without Lahaina, imo. Hawaii and Oahu are about it for liking the area for us.

Bill
Sadly, I'm of the same mind. Poipu has always been my perfect vacation but traffic north/south is crazy. Now with the latest storm damage, I hesitate to make plans. I haven't been back to Maui since the Lahaina fire. We're headed to Big Island is February but not sure what's coming after that.
 
I will say, to the extent I can get a non all-inclusive, I am considering Mexico more than Hawaii, simply because of being closer.
I recommend trying Costa Rica. The landscape really reminds me of Hawaii, especially in August when everything is lush. You can also get all the tropical fruits.

IMG-20260819-WA0081.jpg
 
We have a trip to Hawaii (Kauai and Maui) scheduled for January and February. It may be our last. Mexico may become every year vice every other year. Cost and hassle visiting our favorite places are the main issues. It will be interesting to see how the two Islands have recovered from all the storms this year.
 
Caribbean - sargassum

Costa Rica - traffic and roads are bad

Mexico - sargassum on Caribbean, pacific coast and no AI thank you.

Hawaii - every two to three years now and shoulder season when possible
 
The economics has very little to do with Hawaii, and a lot to do with how leisure activivties are increasingly priced to capture the higher-end of the market. That's happening everywhere. For example, take a look at how the World Cup tickets were priced this past summer---and those stadiums were generally full at those prices. I got a deal on a group stage match between Canada and South Africa that was well under face on the secondary market, and I still paid many hundreds of dollars per ticket for the upper deck behind one goal.

As for the kama‘āina's feelings towards the haole, I think that's been overblown. I've been to all four of the "major" islands since the lockdown was lifted, and it doesn't feel that much different at all---though in fairness Maui was before the fires, not after, and even then there was a fair bit of grumbling about the West Side (and its tourists) using more than its share of the water. Perhaps part of my experience is that I try to be a visitor instead of a tourist, but that's not new either. It's the way I've always traveled there.
 
Hawaii has definitely taken a pretty big hit because of all the terrible natural disasters over the last few years. I do believe once the rebuild of commercial Lahaina starts creating a positive buzz the entire state will benefit and it will once again be a can't miss vacation. Now it's really a wait and see for good news mentality that is dampening enthusiasm for Hawaii but that will change sooner than later I believe.
 
That is what we do. I do like flying to the closer Mexico better than Hawaii other than occasionally getting stuck at the Mexican Immigration and Customs. We have Global Entry so coming home is ok. Non-all-inclusive does limit where we can go. One thing for sure is the resorts in Mexico that we like are more opulent with nicer beaches than anywhere we have stayed in Hawaii. Even so, we do love some places Hawaii.

Bill
ohhh, what places are you usually staying at in Mexico, and can I maybe get them via RCI or II? I don't think Wyndham or HGVC has anything there directly.
 
I recommend trying Costa Rica. The landscape really reminds me of Hawaii, especially in August when everything is lush. You can also get all the tropical fruits.

View attachment 129845
I have thought about trying to use HHonors and free night certs to book that Waldorf Astoria in Costa Rica, but that'll be a far cry from a timeshare. I think I heard some people just book normal rental for $1k or something for a week or two? Or are there timeshares I should look for to exchange into?
 
This quote from the article resonates with me:

"One California resident named Shelley summed up the confusion perfectly – the attitude was that we need your tourist dollars, but don’t really want you."

The stink-eye from locals is definitely stronger now than it was 20 years or so ago. New taxes and fees on tourists are proliferating - we're paying more to visit for a worse experience. We've averaged a Hawaii visit about every 18 months or so, but I'm growing increasingly reluctant to book future Hawaiian travel in favor of destinations that are both more welcoming and less expensive.
 
This quote from the article resonates with me:

"One California resident named Shelley summed up the confusion perfectly – the attitude was that we need your tourist dollars, but don’t really want you."

The stink-eye from locals is definitely stronger now than it was 20 years or so ago. New taxes and fees on tourists are proliferating - we're paying more to visit for a worse experience. We've averaged a Hawaii visit about every 18 months or so, but I'm growing increasingly reluctant to book future Hawaiian travel in favor of destinations that are both more welcoming and less expensive.
Hawaii is a place that thinks they are entitled to your money, not really having to earn it. Many places in Mexico (Cancun) are the same way. Walk into a restaurant there and they would prefer to just hold you by your feet for your money to fall out of your pockets then they send you on your way. Everything is so rushed to just take your money. I guess this isn’t just unique to tourist destinations anymore.
 
I have thought about trying to use HHonors and free night certs to book that Waldorf Astoria in Costa Rica, but that'll be a far cry from a timeshare. I think I heard some people just book normal rental for $1k or something for a week or two? Or are there timeshares I should look for to exchange into?
Marriott has a timeshare there. I would try in off season.
 
The economics has very little to do with Hawaii, and a lot to do with how leisure activivties are increasingly priced to capture the higher-end of the market. That's happening everywhere. For example, take a look at how the World Cup tickets were priced this past summer---and those stadiums were generally full at those prices. I got a deal on a group stage match between Canada and South Africa that was well under face on the secondary market, and I still paid many hundreds of dollars per ticket for the upper deck behind one goal.
And that's probably going to continue - what I feel is missing is the supposed competitors that would jump in on an under/unserved market. For Hawaii, I'm not sure there's a need, if they're full and want less tourists, keep raising prices till you get the balance of income to people you want.

For vacation in general, I think that could start to be what we've been talking about - Miramar beach and such is a perfectly great beach destination with no flights required and well served by timeshares and every other sort of lodging. We've talked about island alternatives, and for most of the US I think flights to Europe and flights to Hawaii range from shorter to Europe to a wash. There are a bunch of Spanish and Greek islands, IDK about prices vs beaches etc myself but there are options besides just the Carribean, which of course is an obvious option.

The other thing I think brought up in one of these threads / articles is the growth in Cruising which can have a long way to grow in that I imagine there's room for a lot more ships / ports(for boarding, IDK for port visits) than exist right now and some lines are buying private islands too. If you want a known cost, resort style lifestyle and to look at the ocean, a cruise might be right up your alley. Especially if your comparison is the AI resort charges.

For all the other things like venue tickets - those are inherently limited I think. Shows can just add more dates / stops but even then the performers can only do so many. Special tournaments are just going to be more TV only I think, which at least to me is more comfortable anyway. But I don't go to those things anyway.

I guess we could hope "second string" things get better with the rising population? I.e. maybe if you can't afford Major League tickets, you could see good Minor league teams play? Or maybe more cities start Major League teams because of so many ticket sales? (Though personally I doubt it as the cities seem to lose a lot of money on those stadiums).

And I guess there's then what might happen with population declines in a lot of places - as population goes down, maybe the experiences go back to older days because there's just less people?
 
Hawaii is still, and will likely remain, our warm weather destination of choice in the winter months. Yes, it’s more expensive than it once was, but so is every other resort area. Remember, there has been almost 30% cumulative inflation since 2021, and travel inflation specifically has been as high or higher than that average. Timeshares somewhat insulate many here on TUG from rising hotel costs, but try pricing Westin, Marriott, or Hilton branded full-service hotels on the beach in the Caribbean. Based on my recent shopping, you’ll be hard pressed to find any under $1000 to $1200 per night.

Other advantages Hawaii has over Mexico and the Caribbean is no language barriers and no questions about personal safety outside of the resorts after dark.

Yes, there is a lot of “chatter” in the media about Hawaiian locals who resent tourism, but our experience is that is a loud and vocal minority. Most of the people we interact with in Hawaii retain a spirit of Aloha.

The anti-tourism sentiment is also not limited to Hawaii. We see locals on Hilton Head Island who feel much the same way. And as owners/part-time residents at a HHI condo complex that is heavily short term rentals, we understand why. Some people are incredibly inconsiderate and obnoxious on vacation. Maybe they are that way at home too, but some tourists give all tourists a bad name.
 
you could see good Minor league teams play?
We lost our minor league team in the last few years. We will be getting a UFL team in the Spring, so I am excited about going to football games.
 
Hawaii is a place that thinks they are entitled to your money, not really having to earn it. Many places in Mexico (Cancun) are the same way. Walk into a restaurant there and they would prefer to just hold you by your feet for your money to fall out of your pockets then they send you on your way. Everything is so rushed to just take your money. I guess this isn’t just unique to tourist destinations anymore.
I think this is true, and this is an issue in tourist places mostly because there are relatively few people that are repeat visitors vs "well, what did Google reviews or maybe Yelp say?". Of course, once you know, you don't go back (Hi Fords Garage in Orlando) - but on a normal once in a lifetime trip for a lot of people, they weren't going back anyway.

I will say, one thing I'm really missing is good places with "regular joe food". I.e. the still generally good places, that charge over $100 a person, tend to also have moved to ever more 'unique dishes' so while the food might be prepared quite well, it's often not something I personally would like to eat. And most of the "standard" American, Seafood, Italian, whatever places realized that they're just trying to scrape out profit and don't need a good product or experience to do that in the tourist areas.

I am tired of the "you don't really have a choice" vs "I actually want to do business with this company again" set ups. Hotel taxes and fees are kind of like this now - it's like 25%-30% on top of the nightly rate in many places. But if you want to go to really anywhere and stay in a hotel, you have to pay that tax.
 
ohhh, what places are you usually staying at in Mexico, and can I maybe get them via RCI or II? I don't think Wyndham or HGVC has anything there directly.

We own the Villa Group aka UVCI. None are a mandatory all inclusive to owners. We own Worldmark which has the Coral Baja and a few others that we haven't been to. We own Vacation Internaionale and like the Vallarta Torre but its very hard to get a winter reservation because everyone likes it.

We trade into the Bunganvillias and use to trade into the Vidanta properties. We also made a decent trade into the Lindo Mar Puerto Vallarta. We have made many trades to the Pueblo Bonito resorts in Cabo and Mazatlan. We were upgraded a few times to the Monte Cristo Estates.

Bill
 
In our 20+ years of traveling to Mexico we have never had a criminal or threatenting episode. Of course there are areas of town you do not go to in the middle of the night. But there are areas in USA Cities we avoid after dark. We only did Cancun once and did not like it. We go to San Jose del Cabo. May go to Cabo San Lucas for a day trip. We have developed friendships with locals. We can easily spend 4 weeks there in the Winter. We always get a rental car and so easily travel to Playa Balandra, Cabo Pulma, etc.

As for Food in Hawaii we find ourselves visiting the local food trucks or places like Sueoka's Snack Shop in Koloa. Perhaps picking up some local fish and produce and fix dinner at our Timeshare.

Most of the comments about how expensive it has gotten at most Hotels do not apply to us because we stay at one of our timeshares. Never stayed at a Hotel in Hawaii. So if the Restaurants get too expensive Patti will cook in or I will grill.

Maybe more time on the BI and ignore Kauai and Maui.
 
Last edited:
Top